Fragrance and intellectual property: how can a perfume be protected against imitation?

A perfume combines a composition, a name, a bottle and a commercial presentation. These four elements do not fall under the same legal rules. Under French Court of Cassation case law, the fragrance itself does not qualify for copyright protection. This does not exclude protection of the other assets (name, bottle, formula) or prevent action against certain forms of imitation. It requires the business to identify exactly what it wishes to protect and the evidence supporting its position.
For a perfume brand, risks arise during the first exchanges with the laboratory, manufacturer or distributor. Who owns the formula? Which information remains confidential? Were the name and packaging protected before public disclosure? A trademark protection strategy must work alongside contracts and other available rights. For lawyers and in-house legal teams, the priority is a substantiated case, not a promise of exclusivity over every similar scent. The response to imitation will depend on the rights held, the signs used and the documented circumstances of production and sale.
Key points in 41 seconds
Expertise and the scope of the assessment
An intellectual property assessment identifies, for a perfume, the rights that can be relied on (trademark, design, trade secret, patent) and the evidence available before any action against a copy. Nathalie Dreyfus’s qualifications can be checked through the official directories: the Paris Court of Appeal 2026 directory (PDF), under trademarks and designs, the Court of Cassation directory, 2025 edition (PDF), and the CNCEJ directory. Listings relate to defined specialisms. A private opinion is distinct from a court-ordered investigation. The engagement is defined according to the matter and the skills required.
Separate the scent from the other creative elements
In its decision of 10 December 2013, appeal no. 11-19.872, the commercial chamber of the French Court of Cassation rejected copyright protection for a perfume fragrance because its perceptible form could not be identified with sufficient precision to be protected as a work. This does not mean that everything associated with a perfume is available for unrestricted use.
A bottle design, campaign photograph or advertising text may, by contrast, be protected by copyright if it is original. The file should distinguish the scent, its technical formulation and the creative elements of the presentation. This prevents a broad claim being built on a right that does not protect the subject matter actually copied. French conclusions should not be presented as a universal statement about every jurisdiction.
Protect the name, bottle and commercial presentation
A trademark protects a sign for specified goods and services. Clearance searches, the specification and territorial choices should precede launch. The owner must also define the uses permitted to manufacturers and distributors. Registering a name does not protect a formula or scent. Trademark rights need renewal and genuine commercial use in accordance with the applicable rules.
The bottle and certain packaging features may warrant an assessment under design law, if they meet the requirements of novelty and individual character. An ordinary shape or a feature dictated solely by its technical function does not qualify for this protection. The date of each public presentation of the bottle should be recorded: in the European Union, a filing remains possible within twelve months of the designer’s first disclosure (grace period), but this period does not exist in every country. Photographs of prototypes and launch materials help establish the sequence of events.
The chain of ownership also requires attention. Paying the designer is not enough: under French law, copyright is transferred only by a written assignment specifying the rights assigned. Agreements should identify the deliverables, rights transferred, authorised uses and contributors to the project. Dated files, approvals and contracts are useful evidence when entitlement or copying is disputed. The assessment should cover both the registered rights and the supporting contractual records.
Registering a scent trademark remains difficult
Removing the graphical representation requirement for EU trademarks did not make every smell registrable. The representation must enable the authorities and the public to determine clearly and precisely what is protected. The EUIPO guidelines concerning smell marks explain the representation difficulties associated with the means currently available.
A chemical formula describes a substance without necessarily representing its smell. A verbal description or sample does not satisfy clarity, durability and objectivity requirements. In practice, a scent trademark application therefore has very little chance of being accepted. The available options need checking with the relevant office against the criteria applicable when filing. A distinctive fragrance and an acceptable representation are different questions.
Trade secret protection requires practical safeguards
Article L. 151-1 of the French Commercial Code sets three conditions:
- information that is not generally known or readily accessible,
- commercial value because it is secret,
- reasonable steps to keep it secret.
Calling a formula confidential in a document is insufficient if it circulates without meaningful controls.
Safeguards can include restricted access, confidentiality commitments, separation of the information shared and version tracking. Teams should identify who receives the complete formula, who may amend it and what must be returned or deleted when the relationship ends. Contractual obligations need to reflect the actual practices of laboratories and service providers. Evidence that safeguards were applied is important, not merely evidence that a template agreement existed.
Secrecy does not provide a monopoly equivalent to a registered right. A competitor that rediscovers the formula by its own means (independent development, analysis of a lawfully purchased product) does not, in principle, infringe the secret, unless it is bound by a contractual undertaking. The file should establish the source of the information and the conduct alleged. A similar smell is not, without more, proof that the formula was unlawfully obtained or used.
Choose between patent protection and confidentiality
A composition or manufacturing process may justify an assessment under patent law if the patentability requirements are satisfied. Development costs or commercial novelty alone are insufficient. The assessment should address technical novelty, inventive step, existing rights and the territories where protection would be valuable. It should distinguish patentability from freedom to operate.
A patent requires the invention to be published, generally eighteen months after filing, in exchange for a monopoly of up to twenty years. Secrecy instead depends on controlling access to information. The choice between these options should precede public communications that could affect novelty. Relevant factors include how easily the formula can be reconstructed, the expected useful life of the advantage and whether unauthorised exploitation could be detected. These approaches are not interchangeable, and their costs and limitations should be explained before choosing.
Assess imitation and comparison lists separately
A similar smell does not, by itself, establish infringement. The signs, goods, packaging and commercial uses need examination. A list describing one perfume as equivalent to a well-known product raises a separate issue. References to another party’s mark and the way its reputation is used should be assessed independently from the fragrance composition.
The L’Oréal v Bellure judgment of 18 June 2009, case C-487/07, held that a list presenting a product as an imitation of a branded perfume is unlawful comparative advertising and may amount to taking unfair advantage of that mark’s reputation. It does not justify treating every product described as a “dupe” identically. The wording, public perception and marketing context remain material. Evidence should record the complete presentation rather than an isolated statement removed from its context.
Unfair competition and parasitism claims may also be considered under French law. They require proof of specific wrongful conduct (for example, deliberately creating confusion or free-riding on another’s investment) and of harm. Resemblance or the success of the original product does not remove that burden. Screenshots, purchases and records should be preserved before the disputed offers change, with collection methods proportionate to the intended proceedings.
The role of the IP adviser
The IP adviser defines the legal grounds, remedies and strategy. It also contributes to the analysis of registered rights, comparison of assets and organisation of evidence. The technical engagement must state its limits: recording a similarity, identifying a sign and examining a formula answer different questions. The weight of evidence also depends on how it was collected (bailiff’s report, infringement seizure) and on respect for adversarial proceedings.
Illustrative case
A fictional brand supplies its composition to a laboratory and develops a bottle with a designer. After launch, it discovers a product referring to its perfume in a comparison list. It wants all sales stopped immediately, without distinguishing the formula, name and packaging. Its agreements with the different contributors have not been collected into one file.
The firm would first assemble registrations, contracts, disclosure records and marketing evidence. It would compare the signs and packaging features, then assess possible grounds, confidentiality obligations and suitable evidence-preservation measures. A technical analysis of the composition would be commissioned only if it answered a relevant question, rather than being treated as an automatic first step.
The aim would be a focused claim and improved agreements for future products. This fictional educational example does not describe a client matter, successful judgment or guaranteed outcome.
A five-stage protection process

- Identify assets. Separate scent, formula, name and bottle.
- Preserve secrecy. Define access and commitments before disclosure.
- Protect signs and shapes. File before relevant disclosures.
- Define contracts. Clarify ownership and exploitation.
- Monitor and document. Preserve evidence before taking action.
FAQ on perfume protection
Does copying a smell establish infringement?
Not by itself. A scent is protected neither by copyright nor, in practice, by trademark law. The claim must rely on another right (sign, bottle, secrecy of the formula) or on wrongful conduct such as parasitism. The legal basis depends on the proven facts.
Does a confidentiality agreement protect the entire formula?
It can contribute, but its scope and implementation require checking. Public information and uncontrolled access raise separate issues. Effective safeguards matter alongside contractual wording and the persons bound by it.
Should a patent be filed before presenting the perfume?
Novelty and disclosure timing should be examined beforehand. The decision depends on the composition or process, patentability requirements and other protections. Assess the consequences before making public disclosures.
Can a comparison list be challenged?
Potentially, depending on wording and context. Trademark uses, comparison rules and any advantage taken of reputation require assessment. Similar smells alone do not determine the claim.
Why work with Dreyfus
Dreyfus assists businesses and their advisers with protection strategy and alleged infringement, coordinating rights, contracts and evidence to define a proportionate response.
Conclusion
Perfume protection begins before launch and must address each asset separately. To review your portfolio, agreements and possible grounds for action, contact Dreyfus for an initial confidential discussion.
Dreyfus & Associés law firm partners with a global network of lawyers specializing in Intellectual Property.
