unfair competition

Unfair competition in France: a guide for international businesses

Two competing product presentations compared as part of an unfair competition assessment in France.
For an international business, the relevant comparison is the offer as customers encounter it in the French market.

A French distributor reports lookalike packaging. Customers mistake a competing website for yours. A former commercial partner appears to be using your launch materials. For a business headquartered outside France, the immediate challenge is to establish what happened locally and which legal response fits. French unfair competition law requires three elements: wrongful conduct, harm and a causal connection. Similarity or falling sales alone does not establish the claim.

This guide is intended for international businesses and their in-house and external counsel dealing with conduct affecting the French market. It explains the main French legal concepts, the records to obtain from headquarters and local teams, and the roles of litigation counsel and an intellectual property adviser. An effective unfair competition strategy in France starts before sending a demand letter: identify the entity affected, preserve the relevant material and define the commercial objective. Stopping misleading packaging, protecting a distribution network and recovering demonstrable losses may call for different measures.

Key points in 41 seconds

Watch on YouTube

Understand the French legal framework before importing a familiar claim

French claims for concurrence déloyale are grounded in civil liability, including Article 1240 of the French Civil Code. They should be assessed under their own conditions rather than treated as a direct equivalent of a claim recognised in your home jurisdiction. Freedom to compete remains the starting point: offering an alternative, recruiting staff or approaching customers is not inherently unlawful. The methods and circumstances matter.

Separate unfair competition from infringement of a registered right. A registration in your home country does not automatically provide trademark protection in France: trademark rights are territorial. Check whether the relevant sign has protection covering France, who owns it and whether the goods and services concerned fall within its scope. An unfair competition claim does not require a registered trademark, but it does not create an exclusive right over every commercial idea.

Where several countries are involved, applicable law and jurisdiction require separate examination. Article 6 of the Rome II Regulation contains specific conflict-of-law rules for unfair competition, including a distinction for conduct affecting exclusively one competitor. The country of headquarters alone does not resolve the analysis. Identify the markets affected and the legal entities involved before deciding where and on what basis to act.

Recognise the conduct that may be challenged in France

Confusion over origin or commercial connections

A competing name, package or website may give customers the impression of a shared origin or an authorised relationship. Preserve the French-facing offer, its sales channels and the surrounding presentation. Misdirected enquiries and messages asking whether a distributor or website is authorised can help establish the context. An assessment of trademark protection in France should run alongside this review where protected signs are involved.

Disparagement of products or services

Negative statements sent to French customers, resellers or industry contacts may raise issues of dénigrement, usually translated as disparagement. Record the exact wording, recipients, date and context. Do not assume that truth alone settles the issue: the factual basis, public-interest context and proportionality of the communication may also matter. Statements about individuals and comparative advertising may require different legal analyses.

Wrongful disruption of a business

Losing a salesperson or a customer is part of ordinary competition. Alleged disruption requires examination of the recruitment methods, use of confidential files and actual effects on operations. Ask local teams to preserve relevant records without accessing private accounts or devices unlawfully. A former distributor’s conduct should also be compared with its contractual obligations, rather than described as unfair competition solely because the relationship has ended.

Understand parasitisme, a distinct French concept

Parasitisme, or parasitic conduct, concerns taking unfair advantage of another business’s efforts, know-how, reputation or investment. It should not be reduced to customer confusion. In its judgment of 26 June 2024, appeals 22-17.647 and 22-21.497, the Court of Cassation emphasised the need to identify a specific, individualised economic value and establish the other operator’s intention to benefit unfairly from it. A product’s longevity or success is insufficient on its own.

For an overseas headquarters, this means locating the evidence behind the product or campaign: dated design files, development records, invoices and advertising materials. Explain which particular value was allegedly appropriated and how the competing offer relates to it. A worldwide marketing budget, without that connection, is less useful than a focused record of the investment behind the feature in dispute.

Assess online advertising in its local context

A competitor’s purchase of your trademark as an advertising keyword is not automatically unlawful. In Interflora, C-323/09, 22 September 2011, the Court of Justice examined whether users could understand the commercial origin of the advertised offer. Preserve the advertisement actually displayed, landing page, search terms, date and relevant location. A search conducted from headquarters abroad may produce different results from one made by a customer in France.

Build an evidence file that connects headquarters and the French market

Nominate a contact at headquarters and another within the French subsidiary or distribution network. Keep originals, dated versions and collection details. Preserve French-language material alongside a working translation, recording who supplied it and the context. Litigation counsel should determine the translations required for the particular proceedings. Avoid replacing a customer’s original message with an English summary that loses relevant wording.

A screenshot can provide an initial record; its evidential weight depends on how it was collected and preserved. A French commissaire de justice, a judicial officer who can formally record facts, may help document online or physical material. Under Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure, a court may order legally admissible measures to preserve or establish evidence before proceedings on the merits, where there is a legitimate reason. This is a targeted procedural tool, not a general entitlement to inspect a competitor’s files.

Involve finance early. Separate losses allegedly suffered by the parent company, French subsidiary and distributor. Record lost margin, corrective costs and disruption, with supporting documents and alternative explanations for changes in performance. A fall in global revenue does not, by itself, establish the loss attributable to conduct affecting France.

Coordinate litigation counsel and the IP adviser

French litigation counsel determines the procedural route, court applications and litigation timetable. The IP adviser contributes analysis of signs, rights, product presentations and investment records. Overseas counsel provides the group’s wider legal context, while local commercial teams explain the market. Agreeing these roles early helps avoid inconsistent demands and evidence gaps.

An IP expert assessment can help distinguish standard product features from distinctive elements and connect the alleged copying to documented assets. Nathalie Dreyfus’s expert qualifications are recorded in the Paris Court of Appeal directory and the Court of Cassation’s 2026 directory; the CNCEJ directory also provides a search facility. Listings cover defined specialisms. A privately commissioned opinion remains distinct from an expert investigation ordered by a court.

Illustrative example: a foreign brand and its French distributor

Consider a fictional manufacturer outside France whose distributor reports lookalike packaging. Headquarters holds the design files and development invoices; the distributor has customer enquiries and samples of the competing product. The brand initially proposes demanding withdrawal of the competitor’s entire range.

Counsel and the IP adviser would first check ownership, territorial protection and the specific elements reproduced. Comparing dated packaging and preserving the French enquiries would clarify a possible confusion argument. The development file would support a separate assessment of parasitic conduct. This approach would produce a focused record for deciding whether to negotiate, seek evidence measures or pursue proceedings, without assuming that every similar product must be withdrawn. This is a hypothetical example, not a reported client matter or a prediction of success.

A practical response sequence for international teams

Assess the conduct, preserve evidence, quantify loss, select a response and monitor compliance.
Coordinate the legal response with the evidence available and the business objective in France.
  1. Map the facts. Identify the conduct, entities and markets concerned.
  2. Preserve records. Gather local evidence and the supporting headquarters files.
  3. Assess the harm. Separate each entity’s losses and document causation.
  4. Select the response. Consider negotiation, evidence measures and proceedings with counsel.
  5. Check compliance. Verify changes across the relevant websites, offers and sales channels.

Questions from international businesses

Can we act if we have no French trademark registration?

Potentially. Check whether an EU or international registration already provides protection covering France. An unfair competition claim can also be considered without a registered right, subject to its own conditions. It is not an automatic substitute for missing territorial protection.

Should the parent company or French distributor bring the claim?

Establish which entity holds the relevant rights and which suffered the alleged harm. The contractual structure and facts determine the analysis. The entity that first reports the problem is not necessarily the appropriate claimant for every loss.

Should we contact the competitor immediately?

Preserve the material first and discuss the sequence with counsel. A demand letter may support a negotiated outcome, but early notice may also affect the availability of evidence. The response should reflect urgency and the conduct that can be substantiated.

What if our own French launch receives an unfair competition complaint?

Retain development records, design choices and campaign approvals. Request precise identification of the challenged conduct and review French rights and market conditions. Independent development records may inform the defence, but do not remove the need to assess confusion or other alleged wrongdoing.

Discuss your French-market dispute with Dreyfus

Dreyfus assists international businesses and their counsel in identifying relevant assets, analysing competing signs and presentations, and organising evidence. To assess a French-market imitation, advertising campaign or alleged diversion, contact Dreyfus for an initial confidential discussion.

Dreyfus & Associés partners with a global network of lawyers specialising in intellectual property.

Read More

Precedent on Opposition and Cancellation Proceedings – 2024

In the dynamic landscape of intellectual property law, opposition and cancellation proceedings serve as vital instruments for ensuring trademark registries maintain integrity and relevance. In 2024, the INPI (Institut National de la Propriété Industrielle) and French courts delivered landmark decisions that clarified procedural subtleties and substantive grounds for action. This article explores key decisions, offering practitioners and businesses critical insights into the latest trends shaping French IP litigation.

Key procedural elements

Non-use cancellation and evidence requirements

Cancellation for non-use remains a critical aspect of trademark disputes. Recent decisions reflect the broad evidentiary approach adopted by the INPI. Undated documents such as marketing materials and screenshots, when evaluated collectively with dated items, have been deemed admissible (e.g., INPI, 2 May 2024, Bob dépannage!). This leniency underscores the need for comprehensive and detailed records of use.

However, the geographical scope of use remains tightly interpreted. For instance, evidence targeting a non-French market (Swiss company) in English were deemed insufficient to establish French usage (INPI, 11 March 2024, Bureau d’Idées), reminding trademark holders of the importance of local relevance.

Procedural standing and abuse of rights

A consistent theme in 2024 decisions is the public interest nature of cancellation proceedings, obviating the need for claimants to demonstrate personal interest. This principle highlights the role of such proceedings in ensuring the integrity of trademark registries and was reaffirmed in CA Paris, 24 April 2024, Vape, which emphasized the role of these actions in cleansing the registry.

Claims of abuse of rights require substantial evidence of malicious intent. In MySunbed (INPI, 27 May 2024), the INPI rejected bad faith allegations where the claimant’s actions were not clearly aimed at harming the trademark holder, setting a high bar for abuse-related defenses.

Temporal scope and legal framework

The temporal application of law remains pivotal in cancellation actions. Decisions such as Cavalride (INPI, 3 April 2024) reiterated that trademarks are assessed based on the legal framework at their filing date, making historical legal research an indispensable tool for practitioners.

Expanded grounds for invalidity

Distinctiveness, deceptiveness, and public order

Distinctiveness remains a cornerstone of trademark registrability. The MySunbed case (27 May 2024) highlighted the evolving standards of consumer perception, particularly concerning basic English terms used in France (INPI, 27 May 2024). Meanwhile, decisions on deceptiveness emphasized the need for claimants to demonstrate misleading potential at the time of filing, rather than relying on post-registration evidence (INPI, 3 April 2024, NL 22-0199).

Public order considerations were addressed in cases like NL 23-0089, where the INPI dismissed claims that a trademark contravened legal restrictions, focusing on whether actual prohibitions existed at the time of filing (INPI, 18 March 2024).

Renown and parasitic intentions

Proving renown remains challenging, as it requires robust evidence such as prior judicial recognition or extensive consumer exposure (INPI, 12 July 2024, Immo Angels). Meanwhile, allegations of parasitic intent require clear links between the litgious trademark and a recognizable external reference, as demonstrated in the Cadault case (INPI, 29 April 2024).

Recent case-law trends in French IP litigation

French IP precedent in 2024 reveals a pro-business tilt, particularly in its evidentiary flexibility for proving use. However, the INPI’s stringent standards for distinctiveness and renown ensure that frivolous registrations face robust scrutiny. This balanced approach promotes a competitive yet fair trademark ecosystem.

Additionally, courts have shown increasing sophistication in addressing linguistic and cultural nuances. The La Chicha Loca case, for instance, highlighted the growing recognition of diverse public perceptions based on regional language comprehension (INPI, 26 January 2024).

Conclusion

The decisions of 2024 underscore the importance of strategic preparation in opposition and cancellation proceedings. Practitioners must anticipate evidentiary hurdles, leverage historical legal contexts, and adapt arguments to evolving standards of distinctiveness and public perception. Key takeaways include:

  • The INPI increasingly emphasizes public interest in cancellation actions.
  • Successful cancellation claims demand comprehensive, evidence-backed arguments, particularly regarding distinctiveness and renown.
  • Cultural and linguistic contexts play a growing role in trademark disputes.

Dreyfus Law firm assists its clients in managing complex intellectual property cases, offering personalised advice and comprehensive operational support for the full protection of intellectual property.

Dreyfus Law firm works in partnership with a worldwide network of lawyers specialising in Intellectual Property.

Join us on social media!

Nathalie Dreyfus with the assistance of the entire Dreyfus team.

FAQ

1. What is the difference between opposition proceedings and an action for invalidity?

Opposition seeks to prevent the registration of a pending trade-mark application, whereas an invalidity action attacks a registration that has already been granted.

2. When may revocation for non-use be brought?

An action for revocation may be filed once the mark has not been put to genuine use for an uninterrupted period of five years. The INPI will tolerate this period only where the proprietor can supply convincing evidence of use.

3. Must a trade-mark’s reputation be national in scope?

No. A sector-specific or regional reputation is sufficient, provided it is objectively established.

Read More

Unfair Competition and Parasitism: Developments in Case Law

Unfair competition and parasitism remain dynamic areas of intellectual property law, continuously shaped by evolving case law. Recent decisions in French courts underscore the nuanced legal landscape, offering valuable insights for businesses navigating these challenges. This article explores recent relevant cases, focusing on distinctions from infringement, damage assessments, statutes of limitations, and the presumption of harm, while addressing economic consequences such as workforce poaching.

 

The commercialization of products, a distinct approach from infringement: Likelihood of confusion and the “Product Range Effect” – Cour de cassation, Chambre civile 1, 25 May 2023, n°22-14.651

In a recent case, the French Court affirmed that marketing an entire range of products designed to imitate a competitor’s can constitute acts of both unfair competition and parasitism. These acts are distinct from infringement, particularly when deliberate efforts create a likelihood of confusion for consumers. This decision highlights the courts’ focus on the “effect of range”, where the imitation of an entire line magnifies the competitive harm.

Victims of such practices now have dual recourse—an action for infringement alongside unfair competition claims—provided they can establish distinct facts supporting each claim. This dual strategy strengthens the enforcement of intellectual property rights.

Assessing damages in unfair competition cases: A proportional and tailored approach – Cour de cassation, Chambre commerciale, 5 June 2024, n°23-22.122

 

This decision clarified the framework for calculating damages in unfair competition cases. The court emphasized that damages should reflect the undue advantage gained by the infringer, adjusted to account for the respective market volumes of the parties involved. This ensures a proportional remedy aligned with the victim’s actual harm, avoiding excessive awards.

Additionally, the court rejected a constitutional challenge to Article 1240 of the Civil Code, affirming its compatibility with constitutional rights and freedoms.

This decision reinforces the importance of meticulously quantifying the infringer’s financial gains while balancing equitable restitution for the victim.

Statutes of limitations in unfair competition actions: clarity on timeframes – Cour de cassation, Chambre commerciale, n°18-19.153

 

In this case, the court addressed the statute of limitations for unfair competition claims. While such actions often involve ongoing misconduct, the five-year limitation begins when the victim becomes aware or should reasonably have become aware of the acts in question. This approach balances the need for legal certainty with the realities of discovering illicit practices.

Companies should diligently monitor their markets to identify potential infringements promptly, ensuring timely legal action.

Presumption of harm in unfair competition and denigration cases: easing the burden of proof – Paris Court of Appeal, October 4th 2023, n°21/22383

 

The Paris Court of Appeal’s ruling reiterated that acts of unfair competition or denigration inherently presume harm to the victim. Whether the damage is economic or moral, the mere establishment of unfair practices suffices to presume injury, obviating the need for exhaustive proof.

This presumption facilitates swift remedies for victims, enabling them to focus on mitigating business impacts without extensive evidentiary requirements.

Economic consequences, workforce poaching and business disruption : the Case of mass recruitment – Cour de cassation, Chambre commerciale, April 13th 2023, n°22-12.808

 

A striking example of the economic fallout from unfair competition is the poaching of a competitor’s workforce. In a significant case, the court deemed the large-scale recruitment of key personnel—constituting a substantial portion of managerial staff—to be a deliberate tactic causing operational disarray. Such actions were classified as unfair competition due to their disruptive intent and effects.

Businesses affected by mass recruitment strategies can seek legal redress, particularly when such actions undermine their operational stability.

Conclusion

The evolving jurisprudence surrounding unfair competition and parasitism underscores the judiciary’s commitment to protecting fair business practices. Key developments highlight the courts’ nuanced approach to addressing product mimicry, tailored damage assessments, clear limitation periods, presumptions of harm, and economic impacts like workforce poaching. By staying informed and adopting proactive strategies, businesses can effectively safeguard their intellectual property and market position.

At Dreyfus, we provide you with a team of recognized experts to:

  • Identify acts of unfair competition and parasitism.
  • Develop tailored legal strategies to protect your interests.
  • Represent you effectively before the competent courts.

Contact Us Today

Do not let unfair competition harm your business. Reach out to Dreyfus for personalized advice and protect your rights with an effective strategy.

Join us on social media!

LinkedIn  

Instagram

Read More

Securing Creations: The Blueprint to French Intellectual Property Dispute Resolution

French intellectual property (IP) law, deeply rooted in civil law tradition, is designed to ensure robust protection and enforcement of IP rights. The French legal framework for intellectual property disputes encompasses civil and criminal remedies, specialized courts, and a highly structured procedural system. This article delves into the intricacies of IP dispute resolution in France, focusing on trademark enforcement, litigation procedures, available remedies, and alternative dispute resolution (ADR) mechanisms while highlighting the essential balance between civil and criminal liabilities in IP infringement cases.

Trademark Enforcement in French Law

Trademark protection in France is governed by the Intellectual Property Code, which outlines the legal avenues available to trademark owners in cases of infringement. The law offers a dual approach whereby acts of infringement can be classified as both criminal and civil offenses. In most cases, trademark disputes are handled by civil courts. However, certain violations may lead to criminal prosecution.

 

For criminal liability, the stakes are high. Trademark infringement can result in substantial penalties, with fines reaching up to 400,000 euros and imprisonment for up to four years for individuals. Legal entities may face fines of up to 2 million euros. While these penalties underline the seriousness with which France views IP violations, the majority of trademark disputes remain within the civil court system, with ten designated courts spread across France, including key jurisdictions like Paris, Marseille, and Lyon.

 

Procedural Pathways in IP Disputes

A trademark infringement lawsuit in France typically begins with a writ of summons, a procedural document laying out the nature of the dispute, legal arguments, and remedies sought. The summons must also contain evidence of the claimant’s attempt to resolve the issue amicably before resorting to litigation. Once filed, both parties are required to be represented by legal counsel throughout the proceedings.

 

The civil litigation process is notably distinct in France due to the absence of a discovery phase. Instead, a claimant can request a search and seizure procedure commonly referred to as “saisie-contrefaçon.” This powerful mechanism enables the claimant, with the assistance of a bailiff, to collect evidence of infringement, including seizing goods and related documents. To initiate this procedure, the claimant must first obtain court authorization, which is granted upon showing a reasonable suspicion of IP infringement. Once the “saisie-contrefaçon” is completed, the claimant has a strict timeline, typically 20 business days or 31 calendar days, to file the main proceedings, failing which the evidence seized may become inadmissible.

 

French courts also adhere to a stringent timeline for rendering decisions in first-instance proceedings, with judgments typically issued within 24 months. This relatively predictable timeframe particularly appeals to right holders seeking timely enforcement of their rights.

 

Burden of Proof and Remedies

As in most civil legal systems, the burden of proof in French IP law lies with the claimant. This responsibility extends to establishing both the occurrence of the infringing act and the likelihood of continued or imminent infringement. In some cases, particularly when seeking provisional relief, such as a preliminary injunction, the claimant must demonstrate that the trademark violation appears likely or is about to occur.

 

French courts offer both provisional and permanent remedies. Provisional remedies can be awarded during injunctive proceedings and may include an order prohibiting further infringement, the seizure of suspect goods, or a requirement for the infringer to provide financial guarantees. Permanent remedies are granted once the court rules on the merits of the case, which may involve the destruction or recall of infringing goods, as well as orders to cease all infringing activities. Additionally, monetary remedies are calculated based on the economic harm caused to the trademark owner, the profits made by the infringer, and any moral damages. However, French law does not provide for punitive damages, and courts retain discretion when determining the final award.

 

Alternative Dispute Resolution: A Growing Trend

While litigation remains the primary method for resolving IP disputes in France, alternative dispute resolution (ADR) techniques, such as mediation and conciliation, are slowly gaining traction. The French government and courts are actively encouraging the use of ADR as a cost-effective, confidential, and flexible means of resolving IP conflicts. One of the key advantages of ADR lies in its ability to preserve business relationships while offering swift resolution, as parties can enter into ADR before or after litigation has commenced.

 

That said, ADR, in the context of intellectual property disputes, carries certain limitations. For instance, rights holders seeking immediate relief, such as a preliminary injunction or seizure order, must rely on the courts, as ADR mechanisms do not provide such enforceable interim measures. Despite these limitations, the growth of ADR signals a shift toward more collaborative methods of resolving trademark and other IP disputes in France.

 

Conclusion

French intellectual property dispute resolution offers a comprehensive, well-structured system that balances civil and criminal liabilities, provides robust enforcement mechanisms, and promotes alternative means of conflict resolution. Trademark owners benefit from clearly defined procedural rules, access to specialized courts, and a range of both provisional and permanent remedies. As the role of ADR continues to grow, the flexibility of the French system ensures that right holders can tailor their enforcement strategies to the unique demands of each case. Through a combination of litigation, administrative enforcement, and ADR, France remains a key jurisdiction for the protection of intellectual property rights.

 

With our team’s mastery of French Intellectual Property Law Dispute Resolution, trademark enforcement, civil and criminal litigation, procedural efficiency, and the nuanced application of search and seizure procedures “saisie-contrefaçon”, Dreyfus Law Firm provides clients with a decisive edge in safeguarding their intellectual property rights. The firm’s intimate understanding of the French legal landscape and its strategic use of provisional and permanent remedies ensure swift and effective resolution of IP disputes. Companies seeking to protect their valuable assets can trust Dreyfus Law Firm to deliver robust defense strategies, minimize litigation costs, and, where appropriate, navigate alternative dispute resolution methods to achieve favorable outcomes. Their expertise in this complex area of law makes them the optimal choice for businesses aiming to secure their intellectual property in the competitive French market.

Dreyfus Law Firm partners with an international network of lawyers specializing in intellectual property.

Join us on social media!

 

Instagram

LinkedIn

Read More