Nathalie Dreyfus

Design protection: key lessons from the SMEG case before the EUIPO

Introduction

Design protection is a key concern for businesses seeking to safeguard the appearance of their products. However, the effectiveness of that protection depends not only on the features of a creation, but also on how those features are represented and documented.

In its decision R 2047/2025-3 of 19 June 2026, the Third Board of Appeal of the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) reiterated that a prior design can only be assessed on the basis of the appearance actually disclosed and that features visible during the normal use of a product cannot be disregarded without justification. The decision encourages businesses to reconsider how they prepare design applications and preserve evidence.

The case concerned a dispute between SMEG S.p.A., the holder of EU design No. 005236536-0007, filed on 16 April 2018 for a refrigerator, and Woods & Go Design S.L., which challenged its validity by relying on an earlier design.

Beyond the dispute itself, the decision clarifies the rules governing the assessment of the individual character of designs and highlights the importance of a tailored protection strategy.

The individual character of a design is assessed through its overall impression

To qualify for protection in the European Union, a design must be new and possess individual character.

Under Article 7 of Regulation (EU) 2026/715 of 11 March 2026, individual character is assessed by reference to the overall impression produced on the informed user, in comparison with previously disclosed designs.

This assessment is not simply a matter of identifying similarities and differences between two products. It requires an overall analysis that takes account of their visual features and the degree of freedom enjoyed by the designer.

As explained in particular by the Court of Justice of the European Union in PepsiCo v Grupo Promer Mon Graphic, 20 October 2011 (C-281/10 P), the informed user is familiar with existing designs in the sector concerned and displays a relatively high degree of attention.

Some features may therefore have a greater influence than others on the overall impression. Their existence and appearance must, however, be established by the evidence submitted.

The EUIPO sets limits on comparisons with incompletely disclosed prior designs

In the SMEG case, the contested design depicted a refrigerator with a retro-style silhouette, two vertically arranged doors, rounded corners and horizontal handles.

The application for a declaration of invalidity relied in particular on a catalogue depicting the SMEG “FAB 32” refrigerator, whose exterior appearance was particularly similar.

The Invalidity Division had attached overriding importance to these exterior similarities.

However, the contested design also included views of its internal layout, whereas the prior design relied upon did not show those features.

The EUIPO’s Third Board of Appeal called that assessment into question, reiterating that a prior design may be assessed only by reference to the features actually disclosed.

The fact that a refrigerator necessarily has an interior does not mean that the appearance of its compartments or shelves can be presumed.

The Board thus emphasised that the absence of representations of certain features is itself a relevant factor in the comparison.

It therefore annulled the Invalidity Division’s decision and remitted the case to it for further examination, without itself ruling on the validity of the contested design.

The decision draws an essential distinction: evidence that an earlier product existed does not necessarily establish what it looked like.

For businesses, this is particularly important when relying on an earlier creation to challenge the validity of a competitor’s design.

Assessing features visible during normal use of the product

The decision also provides guidance on the treatment of features that are visible only in certain configurations of a product.

In the SMEG case, the Invalidity Division had considered the refrigerator’s internal layout to be of secondary importance compared with its exterior appearance.

The Board of Appeal, however, noted that the normal use of a refrigerator involves opening its doors and accessing its compartments.

Its internal layout is therefore a feature regularly visible to the informed user.

Consequently, it could not be excluded from the comparison without sufficient justification.

This does not mean that every feature must be given equal weight. Some features may legitimately have less influence when they are rarely visible, commonplace in the relevant sector or heavily constrained by the product’s technical function.

However, any such weighting must be justified by reference to how the product is used and how it is perceived by the informed user.

The EUIPO thus makes clear that the overall impression cannot be assessed solely on the basis of exterior appearance where other features are normally perceptible during use.

This approach extends beyond household appliances and may also apply to furniture, packaging or products with multiple configurations of use.

Careful filing preparation and evidence preservation strengthen protection

The SMEG decision highlights the importance of anticipating difficulties relating to the representation of designs and the evidence needed to support them.

Tailoring representations to the features to be protected

The views accompanying an application for registration determine the appearance for which protection is sought.

It is therefore essential, from the filing stage, to identify the visual features that contribute to a product’s distinctive appearance.

Depending on the creation, it may be appropriate to show several angles or configurations of use, particularly where certain elements become visible only after the product is opened or manipulated.

Since 1 July 2026, the new EU framework has offered greater flexibility by removing the seven-view limit per design and allowing new forms of representation.

Businesses may also consider separate filings covering different aspects of the same product.

However, submitting more representations does not automatically guarantee broader protection. The views must remain consistent and clearly identify the features for which protection is sought.

Preserving evidence of disclosure

The SMEG case is a reminder that a business must be able to establish not only when an earlier creation was disclosed, but also what it looked like.

A catalogue showing only a closed product may establish that it was marketed without proving the appearance of its interior layout.

To anticipate such difficulties, it is advisable to preserve:

  • dated photographs taken from several angles and showing different configurations;
  • catalogues, brochures and advertising materials;
  • product launch documents;
  • archived webpages depicting the creations.

Such documentation may prove decisive when defending the validity of a design or relying on an earlier creation against a subsequent filing.

Conclusion

Decision R 2047/2025-3 of 19 June 2026 reiterates that the assessment of a design’s individual character must be based on the features actually disclosed and on their perception during the normal use of the product.

It highlights the importance of carefully preparing the representations filed and preserving comprehensive evidence of creations placed on the market.

For businesses, design protection should therefore be approached as a comprehensive strategy combining early filing preparation, documentation of creations and readiness for potential disputes.

Dreyfus Law Firm assists its clients in managing complex intellectual property cases, offering personalized advice and comprehensive operational support for the complete protection of intellectual property.

Dreyfus Law Firm works in partnership with a global network of attorneys specializing in Intellectual Property.

Nathalie Dreyfus, with the support of the entire Dreyfus team.

FAQ

How long does design protection last in the European Union?

A design registered with the EUIPO initially benefits from protection for five years from the filing date. Protection may be renewed in successive five-year periods, up to a maximum of 25 years.

Can a design be protected without registration?

EU law provides protection for unregistered designs for three years from the date they are first made available to the public within the European Union. This protection may, in particular, be relied upon against reproductions resulting from copying.

Can a design be filed after it has been placed on the market?

EU law provides a 12-month grace period allowing the designer or their successor in title to file a design after its first disclosure without that disclosure prejudicing its novelty or individual character, subject to the applicable conditions.

Can a design remain confidential after filing?

Applicants may request deferment of publication of their design for a maximum of 30 months. This mechanism allows the creation to remain temporarily confidential, particularly ahead of a commercial launch.

Does registration with the EUIPO provide international protection?

Registration with the EUIPO confers protection throughout the European Union but does not automatically extend to third countries. Protection in other territories requires consideration of national or international filings, including through the Hague System.

This publication is intended to provide general guidance and highlight certain legal issues. It is not intended to apply to specific circumstances or to constitute legal advice.

Read More

Plant breeders’ rights in the United Kingdom : how to protect a plant variety after Brexit and in light of the SPS agreement ?

Introduction

Developing a new plant variety often requires several years of research, breeding, and investment. For plant breeders, seed companies, and horticultural businesses, the legal protection of these innovations is therefore a crucial economic consideration.

In the United Kingdom, this protection is provided through Plant Breeders’ Rights (PBR), a specific intellectual property regime that enables rights holders to control the commercial exploitation of their plant varieties.

Since Brexit, the UK plant variety protection system has operated independently of the European Union regime administered by the Community Plant Variety Office (CPVO). This development requires businesses wishing to market their varieties in both territories to adapt their filing strategies. This situation may, however, change under the sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) agreement currently being negotiated between the United Kingdom and the European Union.

It is therefore essential to understand the protection requirements, administrative procedures, and territorial implications of the new UK framework.

The legal framework for plant variety protection in the United Kingdom

Plant variety protection in the United Kingdom is primarily governed by the Plant Varieties Act 1997, supplemented by its implementing regulations and the amendments introduced following Brexit.

This legal framework reflects the principles of the International Convention for the Protection of New Varieties of Plants, administered by https://www.upov.int/en/ (UPOV).

Unlike patents, which protect technical inventions meeting specific requirements, plant breeders’ rights protect plant varieties that satisfy particular criteria relating to novelty and botanical characteristics.

The UK system is administered by the Animal and Plant Health Agency (APHA), which is responsible for processing applications and granting rights.

Protection is available to breeders and their successors in title. Where a variety has been developed in the course of employment, the rights generally belong to the employer, subject to any applicable agreements.

The regime covers various categories of plants, including agricultural, vegetable, fruit, and ornamental species.

Requirements for Obtaining UK Plant Breeders’ Rights

Under section 4 of the Plant Varieties Act 1997, a variety must satisfy four cumulative requirements: it must be new, distinct, uniform, and stable, in line with the requirements laid down in French law by Article L. 623-2 of the French Intellectual Property Code.

Novelty of the Variety

Novelty primarily depends on the absence of prior commercialization beyond the permitted time limits.

In principle, the variety must not have been marketed with the breeder’s consent:

  • In the United Kingdom, more than one year before the application date;
  • Outside the United Kingdom, more than four years before the application date, or six years for trees and vines.

This requirement calls for particular vigilance where commercial trials or sales have already taken place before filing.

Distinctness, Uniformity, and Stability

The variety must also satisfy the so-called DUS criteria (Distinctness, Uniformity and Stability).

Distinctness means that the variety must be clearly distinguishable from any other variety whose existence is a matter of common knowledge.

Uniformity requires that the relevant characteristics be sufficiently consistent among the plants constituting the variety, taking into account the particular features of its propagation.

Finally, stability means that the variety’s essential characteristics must remain unchanged after successive cycles of propagation.

These requirements are assessed through technical examinations, the duration of which varies depending on the species concerned.

The Application and Registration Procedure with the APHA

Obtaining UK plant breeders’ rights requires a specific application filed in accordance with the national procedure.

Filing Through UPOV PRISMA

Applications for Plant Breeders’ Rights must be submitted online through the UPOV PRISMA platform.

Applicants must identify the variety, specify its origin, provide the information required for technical examination, and propose a variety denomination that complies with the applicable requirements.

The denomination must enable the variety to be identified without creating confusion with existing denominations.

The APHA then examines the application, the results of the DUS tests, and any oppositions.

Application Fees and Technical Examinations

The procedure involves the payment of administrative fees and, where applicable, fees relating to technical examinations.

According to the official UK fee schedule updated in 2026, the administrative application fee amounts to GBP 769, in addition to DUS examination fees, which vary depending on the plant species.

Where examination reports have already been issued by a competent authority, their reuse may be considered under certain conditions.

It is also important to distinguish the grant of intellectual property rights from the inclusion of a variety on an official list authorizing its marketing. These procedures serve different purposes, although they may be undertaken simultaneously.

Rights Granted to the Holder and Their Limitations

The holder of UK plant breeders’ rights enjoys the exclusive right to authorize certain forms of exploitation of the protected variety.

Section 6 of the Plant Varieties Act 1997 notably covers production, reproduction, conditioning for the purposes of propagation, offering for sale, marketing, importing, and exporting propagating material.

This protection enables breeders to regulate the commercial use of their varieties and negotiate licensing agreements.

In certain circumstances, these rights may also extend to harvested material where it results from the unauthorized use of propagating material.

Protection Limited in Time

The duration of protection is:

  • 25 years for most plant species;
  • 30 years for trees, vines, and potatoes.

The continued validity of these rights is subject to compliance with the applicable legal obligations.

Statutory Exceptions

The breeder’s exclusive rights are not absolute.

The regime provides for exceptions relating in particular to acts carried out privately and for non-commercial purposes, for experimental purposes, or for the breeding of other varieties, subject to the provisions applicable to essentially derived varieties.

For certain agricultural species, the legislation also provides for a farm-saved seed exception.

Under certain conditions, farmers may reuse part of their harvest for propagation on their own holdings. However, this right may be subject to the payment of equitable remuneration, with specific rules applying to small farmers.

The Impact of Brexit on Plant Variety Protection

Since January 1, 2021, the United Kingdom and the European Union have operated separate territorial regimes for plant breeders’ rights.

Previously, Community plant variety protection granted by the CPVO also had effect in the United Kingdom.

Today, a newly granted Community plant variety right no longer automatically provides protection in the United Kingdom.

A breeder seeking to protect a new variety in both the United Kingdom and the European Union must therefore, in principle, undertake two separate procedures:

  • A UK application with the APHA;
  • An EU application with the Community Plant Variety Office (CPVO).

However, transitional provisions provided for Community plant variety rights in force at the end of the transition period, on December 31, 2020, to be automatically converted into equivalent UK rights.

The rights concerned benefited from continued protection under the framework established by the Plant Breeders’ Rights (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019.

This distinction is particularly important for businesses managing international intellectual property portfolios. EU protection must no longer be regarded as automatically extending to the UK market.

Towards a Return to Unitary Protection Under the SPS Agreement?

The United Kingdom and the European Union are currently negotiating a sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) agreement intended to facilitate trade in plants and plant reproductive material. According to guidance published by the UK government, the agreement may allow breeders to protect their varieties across the United Kingdom and the European Union through a single right. It is expected to take effect in mid-2027.

Several questions nevertheless remain open: how this single right would interact with UK national law, whose scope differs in certain respects from Regulation (EC) No 2100/94, particularly regarding essentially derived varieties and harvested material (as highlighted by the High Court in Nador Cott v Asda, currently under appeal); whether DUS examinations conducted in the United Kingdom would be recognized; and the fact that the United Kingdom would have no vote on future changes to the Regulation, which is currently being evaluated by the European Commission.

The agreement also extends to plant biotechnology. The UK government has announced that it will align with EU rules on genetically modified organisms (GMOs), while the treatment of precision-bred plants, governed in England by the Genetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Act 2023, remains under negotiation. Dynamic alignment could lead to the patent transparency obligations of the new EU Regulation on plants obtained by new genomic techniques (NGTs) applying in the United Kingdom. However, the United Kingdom has reportedly requested a derogation for precision-bred crops, so these aspects may ultimately fall outside the agreement.

Until the final text of the agreement is available, breeders must continue to file two separate applications and closely monitor developments in the negotiations.

Conclusion

Plant variety protection in the United Kingdom is based on a specific legal framework, whose registration requirements and legal effects must be assessed independently of the European Union regime.

Since Brexit, breeders must pay particular attention to the territorial scope of their rights, filing deadlines, and the procedures required to obtain protection in both the United Kingdom and the European Union. The SPS agreement currently under negotiation may eventually simplify this situation by paving the way for a single right covering both territories.

An effective strategy involves anticipating commercialization, verifying protection requirements, and organizing both the enforcement and contractual exploitation of plant breeders’ rights.

Dreyfus Law Firm assists its clients in managing complex intellectual property cases, offering personalized advice and comprehensive operational support for the complete protection of intellectual property.

Dreyfus Law Firm works in partnership with a global network of attorneys specializing in Intellectual Property.

Nathalie Dreyfus, with the support of the entire Dreyfus team.

Q&A

How does the right of priority apply to plant variety protection applications in the United Kingdom ?

A breeder who has filed an initial application in a UPOV member State may, under certain conditions, claim a right of priority when applying for UK protection for the same variety. This mechanism generally provides a twelve-month period from the first filing, facilitating the coordination of an international filing strategy. A certified copy of the earlier application must be provided within three months, failing which the priority claim is lost.

Under what conditions can UK plant breeders’ rights be assigned to another company ?

Plant breeders’ rights are intellectual property assets that can be assigned, particularly in the context of an acquisition, corporate restructuring, or transfer of business activities. The assignment must be legally formalized, and the information concerning the rights holder must be updated with the competent authorities.

How can a foreign company obtain plant breeders’ rights in the United Kingdom without being established there ?

A foreign company is not necessarily required to have an establishment in the United Kingdom to apply for protection, subject to the applicable eligibility requirements. However, it must comply with UK administrative requirements, and, where the applicant or its chosen agent is not based in the United Kingdom, appoint an agent with a UK address.

How can a company verify whether a plant variety is already protected in the United Kingdom ?

Official plant variety records can be consulted through the relevant UK authorities. The UPOV PLUTO database is also a useful resource. Searches should focus on the variety denomination, the plant species concerned, and any identified rights holder, while taking account of the potential limitations regarding the completeness and updating of these databases.

What are the consequences of voluntarily surrendering UK plant breeders’ rights ?

Voluntary surrender may result in the early termination of protection, subject to the applicable formalities. Once the rights have expired or been surrendered, their former holder can no longer rely on them to prohibit new acts of exploitation. However, termination does not necessarily extinguish existing contractual obligations or claims relating to infringements committed while the rights were still in force.

Read More

How to protect your trademark and distribution networks

Introduction

Trademark protection goes beyond registration. For businesses, preserving the value of a trademark also requires controlling the conditions under which their products are marketed, presented, and distributed.

With the growth of e-commerce, online marketplaces and parallel distribution channels, businesses face increasing challenges in monitoring and controlling the marketing and distribution of their products.

Businesses may therefore face unauthorized distributors, counterfeit products, or commercial practices likely to damage their reputation.

However, a trademark owner cannot systematically prevent the resale of genuine products outside its distribution network. Within the European Economic Area (EEA), the principle of exhaustion of trademark rights limits the trademark owner's rights where the products have been placed on the market by the owner or with its consent.

How can businesses establish legally secure distribution networks? What measures can they take to combat unauthorized sales? And to what extent can they control the marketing of their products?

Protecting your trademark: an essential first step

Registering your trademark and defining the scope of protection

The first step is to secure trademark rights that correspond to the company's activities and target markets.

In France, registering a trademark with the French National Institute of Industrial Property (INPI) grants its owner exclusive rights over the protected sign for the designated goods and services.

Under Article L.713-2 of the French Intellectual Property Code, trademark owners may notably oppose the unauthorized use of an identical or similar sign for identical or similar goods or services where there is a likelihood of confusion among the relevant public.

For businesses operating in several markets, protection may be extended through a European Union trademark or international registrations.

It is also advisable to protect associated brand assets, including logos, domain names, and, where appropriate, distinctive signs used in commercial communications.

Monitoring the use of your trademark

Registration should be accompanied by regular monitoring.

This makes it possible to identify similar trademark applications, fraudulent websites, disputed domain names, or sellers using the trademark in misleading circumstances.

Such vigilance is particularly important when third parties falsely present themselves as official distributors or authorized partners.

Trademark monitoring is therefore a preventive tool that enables businesses to intervene before an infringement becomes more widespread.

Choosing and securing your distribution network

Choosing a distribution model is a strategic business decision.

Exclusive distribution involves allocating a specific territory or customer group to one distributor or a limited number of distributors. In particular, it enables suppliers to organise the commercial coverage of a market and encourage investment by distributors by restricting certain active sales carried out by other members of the distribution network.

Selective distribution, on the other hand, is based on the selection of authorised distributors according to predefined criteria. It allows suppliers to reserve the sale of their products to members of their distribution network.

This second model is particularly suitable for products requiring specific conditions regarding presentation, customer advice, storage or marketing.

The key distinction therefore lies in the selection mechanism: exclusive distribution primarily involves the allocation of territories or customer groups, whereas selective distribution relies on the authorisation of resellers based on specific criteria.

Both models are governed by Regulation (EU) 2022/720 on vertical agreements and by EU competition law.

With regard to qualitative selective distribution in particular, the Court of Justice clarified in its Metro judgment of October 25, 1977 (Case 26/76) that the selection of resellers must be based on objective qualitative criteria, laid down uniformly and applied in a non-discriminatory manner.

Regulating relationships with distributors

Implementing appropriate distribution agreements

Protecting a distribution network also requires carefully drafted distribution agreements.

These agreements should define the conditions governing trademark use and the commercial obligations of distributors.

They may notably regulate the use of logos and promotional materials, quality requirements, online sales conditions, and procedures for monitoring contractual compliance.

Within a selective distribution network, contractual provisions may also prohibit sales to unauthorized distributors, within the limits permitted by applicable law.

It is important to establish the consequences of contractual breaches, particularly termination conditions and the cessation of the use of distinctive signs following the end of the contractual relationship.

Anticipating risks associated with e-commerce

Online sales are now a major issue for distribution networks.

Businesses must determine the conditions under which distributors may use third-party platforms, social media, or their own e-commerce websites.

In the Coty Germany judgment of December 6, 2017 (CJEU, C-230/16), the Court of Justice recognized that, under certain conditions, a supplier of luxury goods may prohibit authorized distributors from using third-party platforms in a discernible manner.

Such restrictions must pursue a legitimate objective, be applied uniformly, and remain proportionate.

However, this judgment does not mean that businesses may systematically prohibit all online sales.

Combating unauthorized sales and online infringements

Identifying conduct that can legally be challenged

The presence of products on an unauthorized website does not automatically constitute trademark infringement.

Article L.713-4 of the French Intellectual Property Code establishes the principle of exhaustion of trademark rights.

Where genuine products have been placed on the market in the European Economic Area by the trademark owner or with its consent, the owner cannot, in principle, oppose their subsequent commercialization.

Exceptions nevertheless exist, particularly where legitimate reasons justify opposition to resale, such as modifications or alterations to the condition of the products.

It is therefore essential to distinguish counterfeit products from genuine products whose resale benefits from the exhaustion of trademark rights. Furthermore, certain marketing practices may give rise to a distributor’s contractual liability or constitute acts of unfair competition, independently of any trademark infringement.

Implementing a graduated enforcement strategy

Where an infringement is suspected, the first step is to gather and preserve evidence. Depending on the circumstances, screenshots, purchase invoices or a report drawn up by a judicial officer (commissaire de justice) may help document the alleged unlawful practices, identify the sellers and establish the conditions under which the products are marketed.

Once the facts have been established and their legal classification assessed, several courses of action may be considered: sending a cease-and-desist letter, reporting listings to online platforms, or initiating legal proceedings for trademark infringement, breach of contract or unfair competition, depending on the applicable legal grounds.

In cases involving abusive domain names, a specialized procedure, such as the Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (UDRP) or an applicable national dispute resolution procedure, may also be considered.

The objective is to adopt a proportionate response supported by reliable evidence and tailored to the desired outcome.

Balancing distribution network protection and competition law

The protection of a distribution network must comply with EU competition rules, which govern, in particular, the restrictions that may be imposed on distributors.

Regulation (EU) 2022/720 of May 10, 2022 provides for a block exemption for certain distribution agreements, subject in particular to the supplier's and buyer's respective market shares not exceeding 30% and the agreement containing no hardcore restrictions.

Certain practices are subject to particularly strict rules, including the imposition of fixed or minimum resale prices, restrictions on territorial sales or sales to specific customer groups outside the permitted exceptions, and measures preventing distributors from effectively using the Internet to sell products.

Businesses must therefore ensure that their distribution agreements and commercial practices comply with these requirements. Preserving brand image and maintaining control over distribution channels cannot justify restrictions that infringe competition law.

Conclusion

Protecting a trademark and its distribution networks requires a comprehensive strategy combining intellectual property law, contract law, and competition law.

Trademark registration provides an essential foundation, but it must be complemented by appropriate contracts, legally justified distribution criteria, and monitoring of sales channels.

Businesses must also distinguish conduct that can legitimately be challenged from the lawful resale of genuine products.

A proactive approach therefore helps preserve brand reputation, secure relationships with distributors, and reduce litigation risks.

Dreyfus Law Firm assists clients in protecting and enforcing their trademarks by developing strategies tailored to the specific characteristics of the fashion, luxury and jewellery industries.

Dreyfus Law Firm works in partnership with a worldwide network of lawyers specialising in intellectual property.

Nathalie Dreyfus, with the assistance of the entire Dreyfus team.

Q&A

Can a trademark owner impose selection criteria on its distributors?

Yes, a trademark owner may impose selection criteria on its distributors, provided that such criteria are objective, proportionate, uniformly applied and non-discriminatory, in compliance with competition law.

How can a business protect its distribution network if a distributor becomes insolvent?

It is advisable to anticipate this situation in the distribution agreement, particularly by addressing the treatment of stock, pending orders, and promotional materials. However, the opening of insolvency proceedings may restrict the possibility of terminating the agreement or recovering goods.

How can a business protect its trademark within an international distribution network?

It is essential to secure trademark protection in the relevant territories and adapt distribution agreements to local legislation. Particular attention should be paid to competition rules, contractual termination conditions, and parallel imports, which may be subject to different legal regimes depending on the country.

Who is liable when a distributor sells defective products?

Liability depends on the nature of the defect and the role of the various parties involved. In France, Articles 1245 et seq. of the French Civil Code establish a product liability regime under which producers are liable for damage caused by defects affecting the safety of their products. Distributors may also be held liable, particularly where the producer cannot be identified and they fail to identify the producer or their own supplier within the statutory time limit. Depending on the circumstances, distributors may also incur liability on other legal grounds, including contractual liability.

How can the use of a trademark in distributors’ influencer marketing campaigns be regulated?

Distribution agreements may regulate the use of trademarks in influencer marketing campaigns, particularly by establishing rules governing communication and the approval of promotional content. Distributors must also ensure compliance with the advertising transparency requirements laid down in the French Law of June 9, 2023 governing commercial influencer activities.

This publication is intended to provide general guidance to the public and highlight certain legal issues. It is not intended to apply to specific circumstances or constitute legal advice.

Read More

How can the Digital Services Act help combat online counterfeiting?

Introduction

When it comes to online counterfeiting, the Digital Services Act gives trademark owners practical tools: a mechanism for reporting illegal content and ways to challenge a platform that refuses to act. However, these tools only work if they are used properly. In practice, three steps determine whether the process succeeds:

  • establishing the infringement,
  • submitting an actionable notice,
  • then choosing the right remedy.

Regulation (EU) 2022/2065, fully applicable since 17 February 2024, supplements intellectual property rights without creating a new infringement action.

Which platforms fall within the DSA?

The DSA applies to intermediary services that have a substantial connection with the European Union, including when they are established outside the EU. The mere fact that a website can be accessed from France is therefore not enough. The Article 16 mechanism targets hosting providers, and in particular marketplaces that host offers from third-party sellers. A trader that only sells its own products is not a hosting provider for that activity, but its hosting service provider can still be notified.

Not all platforms are subject to the same obligations: they vary according to the nature and size of the service. Arcom explains the categories of intermediaries and their corresponding duties. One useful point: Article 16 applies to all hosting providers, however small, whereas the remedies specific to online platforms follow separate rules. Before alleging that an intermediary has failed to comply, it is therefore necessary to check which obligation actually applies to it.

How can counterfeiting be reported under Article 16 of the DSA?

Establish the rights and preserve evidence

Before any notice is sent, it is advisable to check who owns the right, whether that right is valid and which territory the offer targets. An unusually low price or an unauthorised seller are indications, not proof, of counterfeiting. The pages, dates and seller references should then be preserved. Depending on what is at stake, a test purchase or a bailiff’s report can complete the file.

Prepare a legally actionable notice

Under Article 16, the notice must contain:

  • A sufficiently substantiated explanation of the alleged illegality;
  • The exact electronic location, including the listing URLs;
  • The notifier’s name and email address;
  • A good-faith statement confirming the accuracy and completeness of the information.

The choice of channel also matters. Where the platform offers a mechanism for notifying illegal content that is separate from the form for reporting breaches of its terms and conditions, that is the mechanism to use. It is advisable to keep a record of the text submitted, the attachments, the submission date and the case number. If the form limits the number of characters, the core of the argument must appear in the message itself, with the attachments providing the detail.

To find out more about coordinating online notices with customs monitoring, we invite you to read our article “Trademark protection: coordinating customs monitoring and the fight against online infringement”.

What deadlines and remedies apply after a DSA notice?

Obtain a decision and assess liability

Where the notifier has provided an email address, the hosting provider acknowledges receipt of the notice. It must then inform the notifier of its decision and of the available remedies. Contrary to a common belief, the DSA sets no general 24-hour removal deadline: it requires notices to be processed in a diligent, objective and timely manner.

A notice that is precise enough for the illegality to be apparent without a detailed legal examination may establish actual knowledge under Article 16. The hosting provider must then act expeditiously to remove the content or disable access if it wishes to retain the liability exemption under Article 6. Losing that exemption does not, however, mean that it is liable.

To find out more about platform obligations, we invite you to read our article “EU Digital Services Act: what compliance priorities must companies secure in 2026?”.

Challenge a refusal and approach the right body

If the platform refuses to remove the listing, Article 20 allows a free internal complaint to be lodged for at least six months after notification of the decision. The complaint must be handled by qualified staff, and the decision cannot be based solely on automated processing. Article 21 also allows referral to a certified out-of-court dispute settlement body, although its decision is not binding.

Notices from trusted flaggers are handled with priority, although removal is not guaranteed. This status is not automatically granted to trademark owners or their advisers. Finally, micro and small enterprises benefit from the Article 19 exemptions for Articles 20 to 22, unless they have been designated as very large online platforms.

Where the DSA mechanism itself fails, a complaint can be lodged with Arcom, France’s Digital Services Coordinator. The complaint concerns the intermediary’s compliance with its obligations, not the infringement itself. Court proceedings remain available, in particular interim relief on the basis of Article L. 716-4-6 of the French Intellectual Property Code for trademarks.

How can removal lead to lasting trademark protection?

Document reappearances and repeat infringers

It is not unusual for a removed listing to reappear a few days later under another URL. Hence the value of ongoing trademark monitoring and of a record linking content identifiers, seller accounts, decisions obtained and new offers. A similar username is not enough to prove that the same operator is involved: each connection must be substantiated. This record is what then makes it possible to show that the infringement is not isolated, but repeated conduct attributable to the same seller.

On the platforms concerned, Article 23 provides for the suspension, for a reasonable period, of users who frequently provide manifestly illegal content, after a warning and a case-by-case assessment. The aim is no longer just to have a listing removed, but to act on the seller’s account, without this necessarily leading to permanent closure.

Identify those responsible and prepare court action

Subject to the exemptions provided for in Article 29, Article 30 requires the marketplaces concerned to collect information on their professional sellers and to make best efforts to verify that it is reliable and complete. Some of this information must be made available to users. However, sellers’ identity documents and payment details are not freely available to rights holders.

Where the available information is not sufficient to identify those responsible, a trademark infringement action makes it possible, in particular, to ask the court to order the disclosure of information on the origin and distribution networks of the infringing goods. Article 10 of the DSA governs orders to provide information issued by competent authorities, but it does not give rights holders direct access to all of the seller’s data. The strategy therefore consists in pursuing, in parallel, the identification of those responsible, the preservation of evidence and measures to stop the infringement.

Conclusion

Using the Digital Services Act against online counterfeiting requires above all a solid body of evidence and a remedy proportionate to the infringement. A well-prepared notice often leads to the removal of a listing, but only a sustained approach (ongoing monitoring, tracking of repeat infringers and, where necessary, court action) ensures truly effective online brand enforcement. The DSA does not replace intellectual property rights: it provides an additional framework for enforcing them on platforms.

Dreyfus Law Firm assists its clients in managing complex intellectual property cases, offering personalized advice and comprehensive operational support for the complete protection of intellectual property.

Dreyfus Law Firm works in partnership with a global network of attorneys specializing in Intellectual Property.

Nathalie Dreyfus, with the support of the entire Dreyfus team

Q&A

Is the notifier’s identity disclosed to the seller?

Not necessarily, but anonymity is not guaranteed. Article 17 provides that the notifier’s identity is included in the statement of reasons sent to the seller where this is strictly necessary. It is therefore advisable to limit the data disclosed, in accordance with the data minimisation principle explained by the CNIL.

What risks arise from manifestly unfounded notices?

For the platforms concerned, Article 23 allows the processing of notices from a user who frequently submits manifestly unfounded notices to be temporarily suspended, after a warning and an individual assessment. A single rejected notice is not enough to trigger this measure.

Must buyers be informed that a product is illegal?

Yes, in certain cases. Subject to Article 29, Article 32 requires a marketplace that becomes aware that an illegal product has been sold through its service to inform the buyers concerned by purchases made in the previous six months, in particular about their means of redress. If it does not have their contact details, it must publish the information on its interface.

Does the DSA impose general monitoring of listings?

No. Article 8 rules out any general monitoring obligation. Very large online platforms must nevertheless assess and mitigate systemic risks, including those linked to the dissemination of illegal content.

Can a business obtain compensation for a DSA breach?

In principle, yes. Article 54 allows recipients of the service to seek compensation for damage caused by a provider’s failure to comply with its obligations, under the conditions of applicable law. The breach, the damage and the causal link must be established. A penalty imposed by the supervisory authority does not, in itself, compensate the business concerned.

This publication is intended for general public guidance and to highlight issues. It is not intended to apply to specific circumstances or to constitute legal advice.

Read More

How can you recover a .fr domain name and manage a dispute effectively?

Introduction

A .fr domain name that reproduces your trademark, company name or trade name is not merely a technical nuisance. It diverts traffic, fuels phishing campaigns, undermines customer trust and can block a product launch. To recover a .fr domain name, rights holders have four complementary levers: identifying the registrant through Afnic, the SYRELI and PARL Expert out-of-court procedures, court action and criminal proceedings.

The right choice depends on the objective (recovering the name, stopping fraud or obtaining compensation) and on the economic stakes of the case, within the framework of domain name law.

For more information on out-of-court procedures, we invite you to consult our previously published article: “Recovering a .fr domain name: the SYRELI and PARL Expert procedures”.

Identifying the registrant and securing evidence before acting

The data disclosure request, the first step in lifting anonymity

The data of individual .fr registrants is not published in the Whois directory. Rights holders may nevertheless submit a free data disclosure request to Afnic where the domain name is an identical or near-identical reproduction of:

  • an earlier trademark protected in France,
  • an earlier company name, trade name, sign or domain name,
  • a title protected by copyright,
  • a family name or pseudonym.

Afnic only compares the signs and does not examine website content. It refuses the request where the domain name was registered before the filing of the trademark or the incorporation of the company relied upon.

Ex parte court orders when anonymity persists

If the request is refused, the courts take over. Under Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure, a judge may order, before any proceedings on the merits, the disclosure of the registrant’s identity by Afnic, the registrar or the hosting provider. According to its practical guide for rights holders, Afnic enforces an order lifting anonymity within two days of receipt.

Eligibility and contactability checks, an underused lever

The .fr extension is reserved for persons residing or established in the European Union, Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway or Switzerland. Any third party may ask Afnic to check the eligibility and contactability of a registrant whose contact details appear fictitious. The domain name is then frozen and blocked and, if no supporting documents are provided, the registrant risks the immediate deletion of its entire domain name portfolio.

Enforceable evidence from day one

Bailiff reports, time-stamped screenshots, phishing emails and resale offers form the basis of the proof of bad faith. To explore this notion further, we invite you to consult our article: “How does the bad faith duplicate between registration and bad faith use?”.

SYRELI and PARL Expert: recovering a .fr in two months

The conditions set by Article L. 45-2 of the CPCE

The alternative dispute resolution procedures administered by Afnic, provided for by Article L. 45-6, are based on Article L. 45-2 of the French Postal and Electronic Communications Code. The claimant must show standing and demonstrate that the domain name:

  • infringes public order, morality or rights guaranteed by the Constitution or by law,
  • or is likely to infringe intellectual property or personality rights, unless the registrant shows a legitimate interest and acts in good faith,
  • or is identical or related to the name of the French Republic, a local authority or a public institution, under the same conditions.

SYRELI or PARL Expert: a trade-off between cost and the robustness of the decision

Both procedures follow the same rules, are conducted in writing and in French and result in the rejection, deletion or transfer of the domain name. They differ on three points:

  • the decision-maker: an internal Afnic panel for SYRELI, an independent expert appointed by the WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Center for PARL Expert,
  • the cost: 250 euros excluding VAT for SYRELI, 1,500 euros for PARL Expert (single expert) according to the WIPO schedule of fees,
  • the reasoning: concise for SYRELI, more detailed for PARL Expert, which strengthens the decision in the event of a challenge.

SYRELI suits clear-cut infringements, PARL Expert seriously contested cases.

A controlled timetable and supervised enforcement

As soon as the case is opened, the domain name is frozen, which prevents its transfer to a third party. The registrant has 21 days to respond and the decision is issued within two months of filing. It is implemented at the end of a 15-day period from notification, during which either party may bring the matter before the courts under Article L. 45-6 of the CPCE, the domain name remaining frozen during that period. Filing requires that no court or out-of-court proceedings be already pending on the same name.

Court action: obtaining damages and rapid measures

Trademark infringement and unfair competition

Afnic’s procedures do not allow damages to be awarded or website content to be addressed. Where the domain name is used to sell competing products, divert customers or disparage, an infringement action based on a trademark, an unfair competition action or a claim based on the right to one’s name can secure the transfer, the cessation of use, compensation for the damage and publication of the decision.

Provisional measures to stop the infringement

Article L. 716-4-6 of the French Intellectual Property Code allows the court, ruling in summary or ex parte proceedings, to order, if necessary subject to a penalty, any measure intended to prevent an imminent infringement of the rights conferred by the trademark or to stop the continuation of allegedly infringing acts. Absent a trademark-based action, the summary judge may also order, under Article 835 of the French Code of Civil Procedure, the measures needed to stop a manifestly unlawful disturbance. In practice, the blocking or provisional transfer of a domain name used for fraud can thus be obtained within a few days.

Criminal proceedings against phishing and identity theft

Where the domain name is used to deceive your customers, a criminal complaint mobilises the State’s investigative resources. Several offences may be combined:

In parallel, Afnic offers a specific procedure in cases of identity theft in the Whois directory, allows users to report a domain name contrary to public order and refers phishing victims to Cybermalveillance.gouv.fr.

Building a cost-effective recovery strategy

Starting from the objective, not the procedure

Consider a fictional but representative case: on the eve of the sales season, a fashion retailer discovers a domain name reproducing its trademark followed by the word "soldes" (sales), used to collect bank card data. Provisional measures neutralise the fraud within days and a criminal complaint is filed in parallel. The definitive transfer of the name is then obtained at low cost through a SYRELI procedure, provided that no court proceedings are pending on that name.

The decision grid relies on four criteria:

  • urgency (active fraud or mere registration),
  • the desired outcome (transfer, cessation, compensation),
  • the registrant’s profile (competitor, reseller, former partner, anonymous fraudster),
  • the budget in light of the value of the name and the reputational risk.

Anticipating rather than reacting

Monitoring of registrations, defensive registration of strategic variants and a well-calibrated pre-litigation phase reduce the overall cost of disputes. A clumsy cease-and-desist letter or a poorly framed buy-back offer may, on the other hand, drive up the price of the name or alert the registrant. For more information, we invite you to consult our article: “Domain name monitoring: protecting your trademark against cybersquatting” and our Complete Guide 2025: Domain Name Disputes.

Conclusion

Recovering a .fr domain name is not just a matter of choosing between SYRELI and PARL Expert. Lifting anonymity, contactability checks, provisional measures and criminal complaints make it possible to handle each situation at the right cost and within the right timeframe.

Dreyfus Law Firm assists its clients in managing complex intellectual property cases, offering personalized advice and comprehensive operational support for the complete protection of intellectual property.

Dreyfus Law Firm works in partnership with a global network of attorneys specializing in Intellectual Property.

Nathalie Dreyfus, with the support of the entire Dreyfus team.

Q&A

Can a .fr domain name that was not renewed be recovered?

A domain name that has not been renewed is not immediately available. It enters a thirty-day redemption period during which only the former registrant can restore it through its registrar. At the end of this period, it becomes available again and can be registered by the first applicant, which is why it is worth instructing a registrar to capture it as soon as it is released.

Does the UDRP apply to .fr domain names?

No. The UDRP applies to generic extensions such as .com, as well as to the country-code extensions that have adopted it, which is not the case of .fr. Disputes concerning a .fr fall within Afnic’s own procedures and the French courts. A strategy covering several extensions therefore requires distinct procedures to be coordinated.

Do you need to be represented to bring a SYRELI procedure?

Representation is not mandatory. A company may file its request online on its own. However, the choice of rights relied upon, the characterisation of bad faith and the presentation of evidence determine the outcome, and a rejected request cannot be resubmitted without new evidence.

What if a former employee or contractor registered the company’s .fr in their own name?

The dispute is primarily a matter of contract and agency law. Where the name was registered on behalf of the company, the company may demand its transfer and, failing that, bring the matter before the court. To avoid this situation, domain names should be registered in the company’s name, with centralised access and a return clause in employment and service agreements.

Can a trademark filed after the domain name was registered support a claim?

In principle, and in any event for a data disclosure request, the right relied upon must predate the registration of the domain name. A later trademark may nevertheless be useful where the registrant registered the name in anticipation of a project that had become public, for example after a launch announcement or an information leak, which then establishes bad faith.

This publication is intended for general public guidance and to highlight issues. It is not intended to apply to specific circumstances or to constitute legal advice.

Read More

How should an EU design be represented since the 2026 reform?

Introduction

Since July 1, 2026, the representation of EU designs is no longer limited to fixed views. Applicants may now choose between static views, a 3D file and a video. This choice is far from trivial: the representation defines the very subject matter of protection. It must therefore be treated as a strategic decision, taking into account the actual appearance of the product, future evidentiary needs and, above all, any planned extensions outside the European Union.

This development stems from the second phase of the reform introduced by Regulation (EU) 2024/2822, now codified by Regulation (EU) 2026/715 of March 11, 2026, in force since July 1, 2026, supplemented by Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/138 and by Decision EX-26-03 of the EUIPO Executive Director on electronic communications.

For more information on the reform, we invite you to consult our previously published article: “EU designs: what has changed since July 1st 2026 (Phase 2)?”.

Three types of representation, only one per design

Each design must be represented using a single type of representation. Formats cannot be mixed within one design, but several designs represented differently may be included in the same application.

Static views: up to ten views

The traditional representation remains based on images, exclusively in JPEG format. The number of views rises from seven to ten. This increase is welcome but may still be insufficient for a product with several compartments, opening positions or successive configurations.

Dynamic representation: a 3D file

The product may be filed as a 3D file, in OBJ or STL format. Each attachment is limited to 2 MB for a JPEG file and to 20 MB for an OBJ, STL or MP4 file, and the total size of attachments is capped at 20 MB (equivalent to ten 2 MB static views or a single 20 MB dynamic representation). The application itself is limited to 1 GB and each file name to 25 characters. The object can then be viewed from an unlimited number of angles. This format is particularly suited to jewelry, bottles with changing cross-sections or products with complex reliefs, which ten fixed views could not adequately describe.

Animated representation: a video

A video, in MP4 format and without an audio track, finally makes it possible to protect a movement or a change of appearance. Early filings cover graphical user interfaces, animated logos and icons, but also packaging with a kinematic opening or a lamp whose color changes over the sequence. Static views in several colors could have been read as several distinct objects; the video shows a single transformation.

Practical limits to anticipate before filing

Colors, textures and transparency not rendered in 3D

The EUIPO only accepts the OBJ or STL file itself, without the companion files describing materials. Colors, textures and transparency effects are therefore not rendered. Where these elements contribute to the product’s appearance, a complementary static design remains necessary.

Excluding an element from protection

Dotted lines and boundaries, suited to fixed views, transpose poorly to 3D and video. For a 3D file, the simplest solution is often to model only the part for which protection is sought. For a video, among the techniques accepted by the EUIPO (blurring, colour gradients, frames), blurring appears to be the most workable tool: in a video showing, for example, water revealing a fabric’s pattern, blurring the water allows protection to cover the appearance of the pattern rather than the triggering element.

Key points of attention when filing

  • disable the Fast Track option, which is enabled by default and limited to static filings, before starting a 3D or video application,
  • check how the 3D file renders in the filing interface, as shine or shadow effects may alter the perception of the product,
  • provide the video’s technical requirements (resolution, frame rate, bit rate, codec) to the service provider in advance,
  • check the compliance of JPEG files, some of which are rejected on resolution or color definition grounds.

For a full overview of the procedural changes, we invite you to consult our article: “What’s New in Design Law?”.

A filing strategy to build from the outset

Combining formats in a multiple application

A multiple application may include up to fifty designs. It makes it possible to build a complementary portfolio:

  • a 3D version for the geometry,
  • a static color version,
  • variants of the product.

Consider, purely as an illustration, a fragrance house launching a sculpted bottle: a dynamic design will protect the volume, while a static design will secure the colors and serve as a basis for extensions.

Anticipating international extensions

The new formats are not accepted everywhere. If the first EU filing is made only in 3D or video, the applicant may be unable to reproduce that representation in a country accepting only fixed views, and thus lose the benefit of priority. In countries applying an absolute novelty requirement without a grace period, publication of the EU design may then prevent a later independent filing. Combining an EU filing in dynamic format with a static international filing through the Hague System administered by WIPO (which currently accepts only static reproductions) may address this risk by preserving priority in markets that accept only fixed views.

For more on integrating designs into an overall industrial property strategy, we invite you to consult our article: “Design law: how can it be turned into a true strategic asset?”.

What the representation actually protects

A video only protects the sequence actually shown: other possible deformations of the product are not covered, and protection of a technical principle falls, where appropriate, within patent law. A function does not, however, preclude protection, since the exclusion only applies to features of appearance solely dictated by technical function. An animated logo may also be protected both as a design and as a trademark, as the two rights serve distinct functions.

Finally, the reform confirms cumulative protection with copyright and maintains, while extending it to national designs through Directive (EU) 2024/2823, the rule that designs created by employees in the execution of their duties vest in the employer, unless otherwise agreed. This rule does not, however, amount to an assignment of copyright: employment contracts must be reviewed and service agreements must provide for an express assignment, as the rule does not apply to designs commissioned from a contractor. The new formats also complicate monitoring of competitors’ filings, as 3D files can neither be downloaded nor used from the registration certificate.

Conclusion

The 2026 reform finally adapts the representation of EU designs to digital creations, complex objects and motion effects. The question is no longer simply whether to file, but in what form to represent the creation and how to combine static views, 3D files, video and international filings. This analysis must take place before the first filing in order to preserve novelty, priority and portfolio consistency.

To stay informed of intellectual property developments, we invite you to subscribe to our newsletter and to follow us on social media.

Dreyfus & Associés assists its clients in managing complex intellectual property cases, offering personalized advice and comprehensive operational support for the complete protection of intellectual property.

Dreyfus & Associés works in partnership with a global network of attorneys specializing in Intellectual Property.

Nathalie Dreyfus with the support of the entire Dreyfus team

Q&A

Can a registered static design be converted into a 3D or animated representation?

The representation cannot be amended after filing, except for the correction of minor details that do not alter the design. A new representation requires a new filing, which must itself meet the requirements of novelty and individual character at its own filing date.

How long does protection for a registered EU design last?

Protection is granted for five years from the filing date and may be renewed for further five-year periods, up to a maximum of twenty-five years.

Is an interface or animation that has not been filed protected?

It may benefit from protection as an unregistered EU design for three years from its first disclosure to the public within the European Union. This protection is narrower: it only allows action against copying, not against an independently created design.

Can a design be filed after the product has been shown to the public?

Yes, to a certain extent. A disclosure by the designer or their successor in title is disregarded for the purposes of assessing novelty and individual character if it occurred within the twelve months preceding the filing or priority date. However, this grace period is not uniformly recognized outside the European Union, which is why filing before any public presentation is advisable.

Is there a symbol to indicate a registered design?

The reform introduced the Ⓓ symbol, which the holder may affix to its products, optionally with the registration number, to inform third parties of its right. Its use is optional.

This publication is intended for general public guidance and to highlight issues. It is not intended to apply to specific circumstances or to constitute legal advice.

Read More

What is the UDRP procedure? A complete guide to protecting your domain names

Introduction

A domain name is now an essential asset of a company’s digital identity. Its registration by a third party may create significant risks when it is used to divert Internet users, unlawfully exploit a trademark, organise phishing operations or create a fake online store.

In this context, the Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (UDRP) is one of the main mechanisms enabling trademark owners to recover certain abusively registered domain names.

Its importance remains considerable: in 2025, the WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Center administered 6,282 domain name disputes, the highest annual level since the system was created. More than 80,000 cases have now been handled since its launch.

The procedure nevertheless remains subject to specific conditions. The mere reproduction of a trademark in a domain name is not automatically sufficient to obtain its transfer or the cancellation of the domain name.

Understanding the UDRP procedure and its scope

The UDRP procedure was adopted by ICANN in 1999 in order to provide a specialised out-of-court mechanism against certain abusive domain name registrations.

It applies in particular to the main generic extensions such as .com, .net or .org, as well as to certain ccTLDs that have chosen to adopt it.

Its main purpose is to deal quickly with situations of cybersquatting, namely cases in which a third party abusively registers or uses a domain name corresponding or similar to a trademark belonging to another party.

The procedure does not, however, replace court proceedings. It is a specialised mechanism whose purpose concerns the fate of the disputed domain name.

For country-code extensions, some apply the UDRP directly, while others have established their own dispute resolution procedure or an adaptation of the UDRP. These local mechanisms may differ significantly as regards the criteria to be established, the rights that may be invoked, the way bad faith is assessed, the time limits, costs, or the remedies that may be ordered.

For example, .fr domain names notably fall under the SYRELI and PARL EXPERT procedures administered within the AFNIC framework, while disputes concerning .uk domain names are subject to the Dispute Resolution Service (DRS). .eu domain names also have a specific ADR procedure. It is therefore essential, before taking any action, to verify the policy applicable to the extension concerned rather than automatically transposing the UDRP criteria.

The three conditions to establish in order to obtain the transfer of a domain name

The UDRP requires the complainant to establish three cumulative conditions. They are set out in paragraph 4(a) of the ICANN Policy.

A domain name identical or similar to a trademark

The complainant must first demonstrate that it has rights in a trademark and that the disputed domain name is identical or confusingly similar to that trademark.

The addition of a descriptive, geographical or commercial term is generally insufficient to eliminate similarity where the trademark remains clearly identifiable in the domain name.

Cases of typosquatting, based on a typographical error or a slight spelling variation, may also satisfy this first requirement.

The absence of rights or legitimate interests on the part of the registrant

The complainant must then establish that the registrant has no rights or legitimate interests in the domain name.

The analysis may notably focus on the existence of:

  • a genuine commercial activity conducted in good faith;
  • a legitimate non-commercial use;
  • a name by which the registrant is commonly known;
  • or, conversely, use intended to benefit from the reputation of a third party’s sign.

In practice, the complainant must generally submit sufficient evidence to establish prima facie the absence of rights or legitimate interests. It is then for the respondent, if it is able to do so, to provide a contrary justification.

Registration and use in bad faith

Finally, the domain name must have been registered and used in bad faith.

The UDRP Policy gives several examples, including registration primarily for the purpose of selling the domain name to the trademark owner, registration intended to prevent the trademark owner from using its sign in a domain name, or use intended to attract Internet users for commercial gain by creating an association with the trademark.

Other circumstances may also be relevant: a fake online store, phishing, impersonation, redirection to a competitor, an offer to sell the domain name, a pattern of similar registrations, or the use of clearly inaccurate identification information.

The absence of an active website does not necessarily exclude bad faith. Under the doctrine known as passive holding, the inactivity of the domain name may be considered together with all the circumstances, including the distinctiveness of the trademark, the absence of a credible explanation, or the impossibility of envisaging a good-faith use.

Preparing a UDRP complaint effectively

It is recommended to preserve :

  • certificates or extracts demonstrating trademark rights;
  • available data relating to the registration of the domain name;
  • dated screenshots of the website;
  • observed redirects;
  • emails associated with the domain name, where relevant;
  • offers for sale or correspondence with the registrant;
  • evidence demonstrating imitation, phishing or data collection;
  • the history of the domain name where this provides useful context.

Regular domain name monitoring makes it possible in particular to identify quickly registrations that may justify action.

It is also important not to overinterpret the use of a privacy service. Such use does not, by itself, establish bad faith. However, where it appears to have been used deliberately to conceal the registrant’s identity in an already abusive context, it may constitute an additional factor to be taken into account.

How the UDRP procedure works

The complaint is filed with an approved service provider, such as the WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Center.

Following verification with the registrar, the domain name is placed under lock during the proceedings in order to prevent it from being transferred to a third party. The ICANN UDRP Rules provide that the registrar transmits the registration data to the provider and confirms the lock.

The respondent then has, in principle, 20 days from the formal commencement of the proceedings to submit its response with the possibility of obtaining an automatic four-day extension upon request.

One point must be clearly emphasised: the absence of a response from the respondent does not mean that the complainant automatically wins. The panel must always verify that the three UDRP requirements are established. It may nevertheless draw certain consequences from the absence of an explanation where a particular matter clearly calls for a response.

The case is then examined by a panel composed of one or three experts. Except in exceptional circumstances, the decision is transmitted within 14 days following the appointment of the panel.

For cases administered by WIPO, the standard fee for a complaint concerning one to five domain names and decided by a single-member panel is currently USD 1,500. Since 2026, WIPO has also offered an expedited case processing service aimed at obtaining a decision in approximately one month for certain eligible cases.

Possible decisions and the limits of the procedure

The panel may principally:

  • order the transfer of the domain name;
  • order its cancellation;
  • or reject the complaint.

The UDRP does not allow the complainant to obtain damages or reimbursement of legal fees.

Where a transfer or cancellation is ordered, the registrar normally implements the decision after a period of 10 business days, unless the respondent provides evidence that it has commenced proceedings before a competent court.

This possibility highlights an essential limitation: the UDRPdoes not prevent the matter from being brought before the courts.

. Court proceedings may be preferable where it is necessary to obtain compensation, measures concerning several types of conduct, or a legal assessment going beyond the domain name alone.

Integrating the UDRP into an overall domain name protection strategy

The UDRP should not be viewed as an isolated reaction after the discovery of a disputed domain name.

An effective strategy may combine:

  • defensive registrations under priority extensions;
  • automated monitoring of new registrations;
  • rapid risk assessment;
  • systematic preservation of evidence;
  • notices to registrars or hosting providers where the circumstances justify it;
  • negotiation of an amicable transfer;
  • a UDRP proceeding or local mechanism;
  • court proceedings in the most sensitive cases.

The choice depends on the use observed, the urgency, the identity of the registrant, the strategic value of the domain name and the outcome sought.

Conclusion

The UDRP procedure is a rapid and specialised tool for combating certain abusive domain name registrations, but its effectiveness depends on a rigorous demonstration of the three criteria imposed by the Policy.

The presence of a trademark in the domain name is therefore only a starting point. It is also necessary to examine any rights or legitimate interests of the registrant, the chronology of the registration and the indicators of bad faith.

Early preservation of evidence and the integration of the UDRP into an overall strategy for monitoring and protecting digital assets make it possible to act more effectively against cybersquatting.

Dreyfus Law Firm assists its clients in managing complex intellectual property matters, offering personalised advice and comprehensive operational support for the complete protection of intellectual property.

Dreyfus Law Firm works in partnership with a global network of attorneys specializing in Intellectual Property.

Nathalie Dreyfus, with the support of the entire Dreyfus team.

Q&A

Can a UDRP proceeding be initiated where the domain name was registered before the trademark was acquired?The chronology plays a decisive role. Where a domain name predates the trademark rights relied upon, establishing registration in bad faith may become particularly difficult.

Can a domain name used only for email addresses be recovered?The absence of an active website does not necessarily exclude a UDRP proceeding. The existence of email servers, particularly in a context involving phishing or impersonation, may constitute an important factor in the analysis.

What happens if the registrant changes after the initial registration of the domain name?A change of registrant may, in certain circumstances, be treated as a new registration for the purposes of assessing bad faith. The assessment is therefore made as of the date on which the new holder acquired the domain name, rather than the date of its initial registration. Conversely, a mere renewal or an administrative change to the contact details does not, in principle, constitute a new registration.

Is a UDRP proceeding appropriate where the dispute arises from a former commercial relationship between the parties?This type of dispute may go beyond the scope of traditional cybersquatting where it primarily arises from a contract, partnership or former distribution relationship. Proceedings before national courts may then be more appropriate.

Does a trademark owner face any risk if it files an insufficiently substantiated UDRP complaint?A panel may make a finding of Reverse Domain Name Hijacking if it considers that the procedure was used abusively in an attempt to obtain a domain name to which the complainant knew, or ought to have known, it was not entitled.

This publication is intended for general public guidance and to highlight issues. It is not intended to apply to specific circumstances or to constitute legal advice.

Read More

How can you optimise the budget for managing a trademark portfolio?

Introduction

The cost of a trademark portfolio does not depend solely on the number of registered rights. It also results from filings, renewals, territorial extensions, monitoring, recordals, oppositions and enforcement actions undertaken over time.

As a company develops new products, enters new markets or acquires other businesses, its portfolio can quickly become complex. Some trademarks remain essential, while others are no longer used, cover territories that have become secondary, or are subject to services that no longer correspond to the actual level of risk.

Optimising the budget therefore does not mean systematically reducing protection. The objective is to concentrate expenditure on assets and territories that have genuine legal and commercial value.

Auditing the portfolio before seeking to reduce costs

The first step is to obtain a reliable overview of the existing portfolio.

An audit of intellectual property assets can notably identify:

  • trademarks that are actually being used;
  • trademarks that have become secondary or obsolete;
  • rights held by several companies within the same group;
  • registrations covering goods or services that are no longer exploited;
  • countries in which the company is no longer active;
  • upcoming renewals;
  • any inconsistencies between owners, licensees and operators.

This analysis is important because unnecessary costs are rarely concentrated in a single area. They often result from the gradual accumulation of small expenses: renewing an old trademark, maintaining monitoring in a market that has been abandoned, keeping a defensive filing that is no longer relevant, or retaining a historic portfolio following an acquisition.

The audit should therefore compare the legal position of the portfolio with the company’s economic reality.

An old but relatively low-profile trademark may, for example, retain significant value if it protects the name of a historic business activity or constitutes a central element of a product range. Conversely, a recent registration does not necessarily need to be maintained if it relates to a project that has been permanently abandoned.

Prioritising trademarks according to their strategic value

Not all trademarks within a portfolio justify the same level of expenditure.

It is useful to divide them into several categories.

Strategic trademarks may include the group name, the main commercial trademarks or signs generating a significant share of turnover. They generally require broader territorial protection, enhanced monitoring and the ability to take rapid action.

Operational trademarks concern active products, ranges or services whose economic importance is more limited. Their protection can be tailored to the markets that are genuinely relevant.

Finally, residual or historic trademarks may be reassessed where their use is limited or non-existent.

This classification makes it possible to avoid uniform management of the portfolio.

A company does not, for example, necessarily need to monitor a global corporate trademark with the same intensity as the name of a local product range approaching the end of its life cycle.

Prioritisation may be based on several criteria:

  • associated turnover;
  • territories of use;
  • strategic importance;
  • risks of copying or appropriation;
  • expected product lifespan;
  • marketing investments;
  • existence of licences or partnerships.

Rationalising filings, renewals and territorial extensions

Rethinking filings before multiplying rights

One of the main sources of costs lies in filings that are too broad or insufficiently coordinated.

Before filing any new application, it is particularly important to determine:

  • which signs genuinely need to be protected;
  • which goods and services correspond to the intended activity;
  • which territories have a genuine commercial interest;
  • whether national, european or international trademark protection is the most appropriate.

Systematically filing several variations of the same sign in a large number of countries can generate significant costs without necessarily improving protection.

The strategy should also take into account the lifespan of the project. A trademark intended for a one-off campaign does not necessarily need to be managed in the same way as a corporate trademark intended to be used for several decades.

Reassessing renewals

Renewal is a particularly appropriate time to reassess the value of a right.

Instead of automatically renewing the entire portfolio, it is preferable to verify:

  • whether the trademark is still in use;
  • whether the goods or services covered remain relevant;
  • whether the territory concerned remains strategic;
  • whether the right still has a defensive value;
  • whether more recent rights have made the older registration redundant.

This review must nevertheless remain cautious: abandoning a right may permanently reduce the possibilities for taking action against third parties.

Adapting geographical coverage

Territorial coverage is often one of the main budgetary levers.

A company operating in ten countries does not necessarily have an interest in maintaining rights in several dozen territories if no expansion, production or particular exposure to risk is envisaged there.

It may, however, be relevant to maintain protection in certain countries even in the absence of direct sales, particularly where manufacturers, major distributors or markets especially exposed to bad-faith filings are located there.

Optimisation therefore consists less in mechanically reducing the number of territories than in ensuring that each maintained right is justified by an identifiable need.

Adapting monitoring and enforcement to actual risks

Monitoring new trademark applications is another area in which expenditure can be adjusted.

Overly broad monitoring can generate a large volume of irrelevant alerts and, consequently, additional analysis costs.

It is preferable to define parameters that are proportionate to each asset:

  • trademarks to be monitored;
  • territories;
  • classes of goods or services;
  • degree of similarity sought;
  • competitors or particularly sensitive sectors.

The same logic should apply to enforcement actions.

Not every detection justifies an opposition or litigation. The decision to intervene may notably take into account the similarity between the signs, the goods concerned, the third party’s actual use, the territory and the potential commercial impact.

An internal prioritisation policy therefore makes it possible to distinguish situations requiring immediate action from those that may instead be monitored or addressed through an amicable approach.

Centralising management to avoid unnecessary costs

A significant share of costs may arise not from the portfolio itself, but from the way it is organised.

Where information is dispersed among several subsidiaries, law firms, internal spreadsheets or contacts, the company risks multiplying instructions, searches and administrative operations.

Centralisation can notably make it possible to:

  • maintain a single calendar of deadlines;
  • avoid duplicate filings;
  • quickly identify the rights concerned by a transaction;
  • monitor budgets by trademark, country or business unit;
  • rationalise changes of ownership or address;
  • consolidate certain instructions.

A centralised portfolio management tool, can also make it easier to obtain an overall view of registered and pending rights, monitoring services and administrative information.

A well-documented portfolio also facilitates acquisitions, licences, audits or restructuring operations.

It may be useful to monitor a few simple indicators on a regular basis: number of active rights, annual cost per strategic trademark, cost per territory, number of abandoned renewals, volume of monitoring alerts and budget devoted to enforcement actions.

Conclusion

Optimising the budget for managing a trademark portfolio does not mean protecting less, but protecting in a more targeted way.

Portfolio audits, asset prioritisation, renewal reviews, adaptation of territorial coverage and rationalisation of monitoring make it possible to concentrate resources on rights that have genuine value.

This approach should be repeated regularly, particularly in the context of an acquisition, restructuring, geographical expansion or change in commercial strategy.

Dreyfus Law Firm assists its clients in managing complex intellectual property matters, offering personalised advice and comprehensive operational support for the complete protection of intellectual property.

Dreyfus Law Firm works in partnership with a global network of attorneys specialising in Intellectual Property.

Nathalie Dreyfus, with the support of the entire Dreyfus team.

Q&A

How can subsidiaries and acquired companies be integrated into an overall trademark management policy?

An effective portfolio policy should take into account rights held by the different entities within the group. It may be useful to harmonise ownership, internal procedures and decision-making rules in order to avoid duplication and inconsistencies.

Should a specific budget be allocated to trademarks at the launch stage?

When a new trademark is being launched, certain costs may be concentrated over a short period: searches, filings, domain names, contracts or preventive actions. Anticipating these expenses makes it easier to distribute the overall portfolio budget.

How can the profitability of a trademark within a portfolio be assessed?

The value of a trademark may be assessed on the basis of several factors: associated turnover, margin, strategic importance, licensing potential, reputation, markets covered or role within a product range. This analysis can help guide future spending decisions.

Should domain names be included in the trademark management budget?

Where they are directly linked to strategic trademarks, domain names often constitute a complementary element of protection. Their registration, renewal, monitoring and enforcement can therefore be integrated into an overall budget strategy.

How can the costs associated with a portfolio reorganisation be anticipated?

A merger, assignment, change of company name or restructuring may involve numerous recordals and formalities before intellectual property offices. Identifying them in advance makes it possible to budget for these operations and avoid fragmented administrative costs.

This publication is intended for general public guidance and to highlight issues. It is not intended to apply to specific circumstances or to constitute legal advice.

Read More

Are clothing and jewellery considered similar under trademark law?

Introduction

Can a company selling clothing oppose the registration of a similar trademark for jewellery? Conversely, can a jewellery manufacturer prevent the use of a similar sign for ready-to-wear clothing?

These questions are particularly relevant in the fashion industry, where businesses regularly diversify their activities across clothing, jewellery, leather goods and accessories.

Under trademark law, the answer depends, in particular, on the similarity of the goods, a fundamental concept in assessing the likelihood of confusion between two trademarks.

Traditionally, clothing and jewellery have been considered distinct categories of goods. However, evolving commercial practices and recent judicial decisions call for a more nuanced approach.

The judgment delivered by the Paris Court of Appeal on May 29, 2026 (Case No. 25/02196) illustrates this development by recognising, in the circumstances of the case, a similarity between jewellery, clothing and various fashion accessories.

The classification of clothing and jewellery does not determine their similarity

Goods belonging to different classes

When a company files a trademark application, it must specify the goods and services for which it seeks protection.

These goods and services are classified under the International Nice Classification, which includes, in particular:

  • Class 14 : jewellery, precious and semi-precious stones, and watches and other timepieces;
  • Class 25 : clothing, footwear and headwear.

This distinction serves an administrative purpose. It does not mean that goods belonging to different classes are necessarily dissimilar.

Indeed, goods falling within different classes may be considered legally similar where they share sufficiently close connections.

Conversely, goods belonging to the same class are not automatically considered similar.

The principle of speciality in trademark law

Trademark law is based on the principle of speciality, under which the protection conferred by a trademark is, in principle, limited to the goods and services for which it is registered.

However, such protection may extend to similar goods or services, provided that the legal requirements for establishing a likelihood of confusion are met. Article 8(1)(b) of Regulation (EU) 2017/1001 allows the proprietor of an earlier trademark to oppose the registration of a later trademark where the identity or similarity of the signs, combined with the identity or similarity of the goods or services concerned, is likely to give rise to a likelihood of confusion on the part of the relevant public.

Accordingly, a trademark registered for jewellery may potentially be invoked against a later trademark designating clothing, provided that a sufficient degree of similarity between the goods and a likelihood of confusion can be established.

The legal criteria for assessing the similarity of goods

Criteria established by European case law

In its landmark judgment of September 29, 1998, Canon (C-39/97), the Court of Justice of the European Union established the criteria for assessing the similarity of goods.

This assessment must take account of all relevant factors characterising the relationship between the goods, including:

  • their nature and characteristics;
  • their intended purpose and method of use;
  • whether they are in competition with one another;
  • their complementarity;
  • their distribution channels and usual commercial origin.

The objective is to determine whether consumers may reasonably believe that the goods originate from the same undertaking or from economically linked undertakings.

Complementarity must be legally relevant

Clothing and jewellery are frequently combined to create an outfit.

However, mere aesthetic complementarity is not necessarily sufficient to establish legal similarity.

The fact that a necklace may be worn with a dress does not automatically mean that these goods have a sufficiently close connection under trademark law.

Conversely, the fact that they are commonly marketed under the same brand, sold through the same stores and targeted at a similar customer base may constitute a relevant factor.

Consumers' perception of the commercial origin of the goods therefore remains decisive.

The evolution of case law in response to practices in the fashion industry

Business diversification is changing consumer habits

The fashion industry has undergone considerable changes.

Many companies now simultaneously market clothing, jewellery, footwear and accessories under the same trademark.

This diversification has been accompanied by a convergence of distribution channels, particularly through multi-brand stores and e-commerce platforms.

Consumers are therefore increasingly accustomed to finding different categories of fashion products marketed under a common commercial identity.

These practices have led to greater importance being placed on the economic realities of the market when assessing the similarity of goods.

The Paris Court of Appeal judgment of May 29, 2026

This development is illustrated by the judgment delivered by the Paris Court of Appeal on May 29, 2026 (Case No. 25/02196).

The dispute involved Amaya Développement Holding, owner of the earlier trademarks AMAYA and L'ATELIER D'AMAYA, and AME, owner of the semi-figurative trademark AMEIA PARIS.

The earlier trademarks notably covered jewellery products, while the contested trademark designated clothing and various accessories.

The Court of Appeal upheld the decision of the French National Institute of Industrial Property (INPI), which had declared the contested trademark partially invalid on the grounds of a likelihood of confusion with the earlier trademarks.

In assessing the similarity of the goods, the Court notably considered:

  • their belonging to the fashion industry;
  • the diversification of businesses marketing both clothing and jewellery;
  • the existence of common distribution channels;
  • the average consumer's perception that the goods may originate from the same commercial undertaking;
  • their frequent combination in the creation of an outfit.

The Court also found a very high degree of visual and phonetic similarity between the signs AMAYA and AMEIA, which, in view of the similarity of the goods, supported the existence of a likelihood of confusion as to their commercial origin.

This judgment confirms that differences in the nature or intended purpose of goods do not preclude a finding of similarity under trademark law, where market practices and consumer perception suggest that the goods may originate from the same commercial undertaking.

However, it does not mean that all goods falling within Classes 14 and 25 must systematically be considered similar. The assessment remains fact-specific and depends on the circumstances of each case.

Adapting trademark protection strategies

For businesses operating in the fashion and jewellery sectors, this case law highlights the importance of adopting a trademark protection strategy that reflects market practices and potential business diversification.

When filing a trademark application, it is essential to identify the categories of goods actually marketed and any commercial extensions that are seriously envisaged.

Trademark clearance searches should not necessarily be limited to the class corresponding to the company's main activity.

It may also be appropriate to examine trademarks registered for goods that are economically closely related.

In opposition or invalidity proceedings, the similarity of goods may be demonstrated through concrete evidence, such as catalogues, collections, e-commerce websites, distribution channels, or diversification practices within the relevant industry.

An argument based on market realities may therefore prove decisive in establishing, or challenging, the similarity between clothing and jewellery.

Conclusion

Clothing and jewellery are neither systematically similar nor necessarily dissimilar under trademark law.

Although differences in their nature and function have traditionally justified a restrictive approach, evolving commercial practices are leading certain courts to recognise their economic proximity.

The Paris Court of Appeal judgment of May 29, 2026 illustrates this approach, without calling into question the need for an individual assessment of each case.

For businesses, the challenge is therefore to look beyond the categories established by the Nice Classification and anticipate the risks associated with brand diversification.

Dreyfus Law Firm assists clients in protecting and enforcing their trademarks by developing strategies tailored to the specific characteristics of the fashion, luxury and jewellery industries.

Dreyfus Law Firm works in partnership with a worldwide network of lawyers specialising in intellectual property.

Nathalie Dreyfus, with the assistance of the entire Dreyfus team.

This publication is intended to provide general guidance to the public and highlight certain legal issues. It is not intended to address specific circumstances or constitute legal advice.

Q&A

Can a trademark registered for jewellery prevent the registration of a similar trademark for clothing?

Such an opposition is possible, even where the goods fall within different classes. However, the proprietor of the earlier trademark must demonstrate a likelihood of confusion, taking into account, in particular, the similarity of the signs, the commercial proximity of the goods, their distribution channels, and consumer perception. The assessment therefore depends on the specific circumstances of each case.

Does use of a trademark for clothing preserve its protection for jewellery?

Under French and European Union law, a trademark may be subject to revocation if it has not been put to genuine use for an uninterrupted period of five years, unless there are proper reasons for non-use. Revocation may be limited to the goods for which genuine use has not been demonstrated. Consequently, using a trademark for clothing will not necessarily be sufficient to maintain its protection for jewellery.

Can the sale of counterfeit jewellery on an online platform give rise to liability for the seller?

Marketing jewellery that infringes a protected trademark may constitute trademark infringement. The trademark owner may notably request the removal of the infringing listings and initiate legal proceedings against the seller. Depending on the circumstances, measures may also be sought from the platform concerned.

Can a company protect the design of a piece of jewellery independently of its trademark?

The appearance of a piece of jewellery may benefit from design protection where the applicable requirements are met, particularly novelty and individual character. It may also benefit from copyright protection, provided that it constitutes an original work reflecting the author's personality through free and creative choices.

What should a company do if it discovers that a competitor is using a trademark similar to its own?

The first step is to assess the likelihood of confusion between the signs, particularly in light of the goods or services concerned, and to determine the scope of the earlier rights. Depending on the circumstances, several courses of action may be considered: opposition proceedings if the trademark application is still pending, invalidity proceedings if the trademark has already been registered, or trademark infringement proceedings where the proprietor's rights have been infringed. An amicable settlement may also be sought. The choice of strategy depends on the legal circumstances and the commercial interests at stake in the dispute.

Read More

Who is responsible for the actions of autonomous AI agents?

Introduction

The increasing integration of agentic artificial intelligence into business operations raises new legal questions. Unlike traditional AI systems, which generally produce responses or recommendations, autonomous AI agents can make decisions and carry out actions without systematic human intervention. In particular, they may place orders, interact with business partners, publish content or process confidential data. But who is responsible when an AI agent enters into an unauthorized contract, infringes intellectual property rights or discloses sensitive information? As AI has no legal personality, it cannot itself be held legally liable for its actions. Responsibility must therefore be determined among the various parties involved in its development, deployment and use, taking into account their respective legal obligations, the authority granted to the system and the measures implemented to prevent foreseeable risks.

Why does agentic AI change the legal risk assessment?

From generating an answer to carrying out an action

Unlike a generative AI assistant mainly used to produce content, an AI agent can plan and carry out a sequence of actions to achieve a set objective, using various digital tools and services, without systematic human validation.

Its discretion over how to achieve the objective makes certain outcomes difficult to anticipate. The EU definition of an AI system covers varying levels of autonomy; technical independence, however, does not establish separate legal capacity.

Consider a hypothetical marketing department instructing an agent to launch a campaign. In pursuit of the deadline, it buys stock images, reproduces a protected illustration and distributes advertisements on several platforms. The objective was authorised, but some of the means were not. This example highlights why businesses must monitor intermediate actions, not merely evaluate the final deliverable.

Who is liable for contracts and harm caused by an AI agent?

The business deploying the agent and the authority it appears to hold

If an agent negotiates or pays using corporate credentials, the business is exposed to the legal consequences of the transactions carried out.

However, the agent’s technical autonomy confers on it neither legal personality nor any power of representation of its own. Whether the business is bound must be assessed in light of the conditions under which the agent was deployed, the permissions granted and the circumstances of each transaction.

Under French law, Article 1156 of the Civil Code protects, under certain conditions, a third party who legitimately believed in a representative’s authority. Its application to transactions carried out by an AI agent cannot, however, be presumed, as such an agent cannot be legally equated with an authorised representative.

To limit these risks, businesses should precisely define the authorised transactions, set financial caps and require human approval for the most sensitive commitments.

Providers, integrators and deployers: different sources of liability

Where an AI agent causes harm, the liability of each party must be assessed in light of its respective role in the design, integration, deployment and use of the system. A design defect may implicate the provider; unsafe customisation, the integrator; inadequate monitoring, the deploying business. Under the general fault-based rules of French civil law, fault, damage and causation must be established. Using AI does not automatically make every participant liable, nor does unpredictability automatically release them from responsibility.

The Canadian decision Moffatt v. Air Canada, 2024 BCCRT 149 illustrates the issue: the airline was held liable for incorrect information supplied through its chatbot. This foreign decision concerned a conversational assistant rather than an autonomous agent, and is not binding in the EU. It nevertheless undermines the assumption that a company can escape responsibility by describing its interface as a separate entity.

For further information on AI liability for infringing third-party rights, we invite you to read our article “Can AI be held liable for infringement or plagiarism?”.

How do the EU AI Act and related laws allocate obligations?

The AI Act governs functions, not a universal right to compensation

The EU AI Act distinguishes between providers and deployers. For high-risk systems, it establishes duties concerning documentation, monitoring and human oversight, subject to the applicable implementation timetable. Substantial modifications or changes in intended purpose can also shift certain provider obligations along the supply chain (Article 25 of the AI Act). Importantly, the AI Act does not itself create a comprehensive civil-liability regime: claims must be assessed under private-law and sector-specific rules.

The revised Product Liability Directive (EU) 2024/2853 expressly covers software. Member States must transpose it by 9 December 2026; the revised framework concerns products placed on the market or put into service after 9 December 2026. This does not turn every mistaken AI response into a defective-product claim.

For further information on the AI Act, we invite you to read our article “The EU AI Act and Its Implications for Global Business”.

Personal data and online platforms: context-specific duties

An agent arranging business travel or contacting prospects may process identities, contact details and sensitive information. Under the GDPR, the controller–processor distinction depends on who determines the purposes and means of processing, not automatically on AI Act labels. France’s data protection authority, the CNIL, recommends documenting responsibilities, risks and security controls. Where an agent publishes content through hosting services, the Digital Services Act may provide notice-and-action procedures for reporting illegal material without shifting all responsibility for the agent to the host.

For further information on how AI and the GDPR interact, we invite you to read our article “AI and Data Privacy”.

How can intellectual property infringements by AI agents be prevented?

Control sources, permissions and external publication

Relevant risks include unauthorised copying of copyrighted works, misuse of distinctive signs, misleading visuals and disclosure of trade secrets. An agent connected to stock-image libraries, advertising dashboards or code repositories may repeat these acts within minutes. Companies should verify licences before granting access, restrict available sources and require human review before commercially significant material is released.

For detailed guidance on output checks, we invite you to read our article “How can copyright infringement be avoided when using artificial intelligence?”.

What governance should companies establish before deployment?

Effective control requires an auditable chain of decisions, proportionate to the consequences of the agent’s actions. Contractual safeguards should operate alongside technical restrictions that demonstrably work:

  • Define the operating mandate: objectives, permitted applications, accessible data and financial thresholds;
  • Gate critical actions: obtain human approval for payments, publications, contractual commitments and sensitive transfers;
  • Map suppliers and contracts: allocate duties relating to licences, incidents, assurances, audits and cooperation;
  • Preserve evidence: retain instructions, activity logs, content versions, alerts and emergency shutdown procedures.

For relevant high-risk systems, Article 26 of the AI Act specifies deployer obligations relating, among other matters, to monitoring and human oversight. Compliance is not a policy stored on a server: safeguards need testing, actual use and reassessment following significant changes.

For further information on the use of AI within companies, we invite you to read our article “Can artificial intelligence be freely used in the workplace?”.

Conclusion

Autonomous AI liability is not a legal vacuum. It follows the acts performed, the risks that could reasonably be anticipated, the powers enabled and each organisation’s legal obligations. As agents gain freedom to act, enforceable contractual limits, controlled access, intellectual property clearance and reliable evidence of system behaviour become essential.

Dreyfus Law Firm assists its clients in managing complex intellectual property cases, offering personalised advice and comprehensive operational support for the complete protection of intellectual property.

Dreyfus Law Firm works in partnership with a global network of attorneys specialising in intellectual property.

Nathalie Dreyfus, with the support of the entire Dreyfus team

Q&A

Must an autonomous AI agent tell a customer that it is not human?

In the situations covered by Article 50 of the AI Act, individuals must be informed that they are interacting with AI, subject to statutory exceptions. The nature of the interface and the respective roles of the provider and deployer matter.

What clauses should a contract with an AI agent provider include?

The contract should, in particular, set out each party’s obligations, security and confidentiality guarantees, the conditions for data use and intellectual property rights. It is also essential to include clauses on liability, incident management and the arrangements for auditing and monitoring the system.

Does cyber insurance cover losses caused by autonomous AI?

Not necessarily. Coverage depends on the policy wording, including professional negligence, automated acts, third-party IP claims, notification conditions and applicable exclusions, limits and deductibles. An explicit review of AI-related risks is advisable.

What if an AI agent sends personal data to a supplier outside the EU?

The transfer requires an appropriate GDPR mechanism, such as an adequacy decision or standard contractual clauses together with supplementary safeguards where needed. Businesses should identify the locations of infrastructure and subprocessors.

Can an autonomous AI system be named as the inventor on a patent application?

Under the current European framework, the named inventor must be a natural person. AI-assisted inventions may still be patentable, but the human inventive contribution and the usual patentability conditions must be established.

For further information on AI and patent law, we invite you to read our article “Patents and the question of AI as inventor: what are the prospects following recent decisions?”.

This publication is intended for general public guidance and to highlight issues. It is not intended to apply to specific circumstances or to constitute legal advice.

Read More