The UK Supreme Court’s decision in SkyKick UK Ltd and another v. Sky Ltd and others has significantly impacted trademark law, particularly concerning the breadth of specifications and the concept of bad faith. This ruling underscores the importance of aligning trademark specifications with genuine commercial intentions.

Background of the SkyKick v Sky Case

In 2016, Sky Ltd, a prominent broadcaster and telecommunications company, initiated legal proceedings against SkyKick, a US-based cloud management software provider, alleging trade mark infringement. Sky’s claims were based on its extensive trade mark registrations covering a wide array of goods and services. SkyKick countered by challenging the validity of Sky’s trademarks, asserting that they were registered in bad faith due to their overly broad specifications without genuine intent to use the marks across all listed categories.

Legal framework and Supreme Court’s findings

Understanding bad faith in trademark law

Under Section 3(6) of the UK Trade Marks Act 1994, a trademark shall not be registered if the application is made in bad faith. The concept of bad faith involves a lack of genuine intention to use the trade mark for the goods and services specified at the time of application.

Supreme Court’s analysis

The Supreme Court held that:

  • Overly broad specifications: Filing for a wide range of goods and services without a genuine intention to use the trade mark for all of them can indicate bad faith.
  • Assessment of intent: The applicant’s intention at the time of filing is crucial. A lack of intention to use the mark for certain goods or services, especially when the specification is excessively broad, supports a finding of bad faith.
  • Partial invalidity: If bad faith is established for certain goods or services, the trade mark can be partially invalidated for those specific categories.

This decision emphasizes that trade mark applications must reflect a genuine commercial strategy and not serve as a means to unjustly monopolize market segments.

Implications for trademark applicants

Strategic considerations

Trademark applicants should:

  • Align specifications with business activities: Ensure that the goods and services listed in the application correspond to current or planned business operations.
  • Avoid overly broad terms: Refrain from using vague or broad categories without a clear intention to use the trade mark across all specified areas.
  • Maintain documentation: Keep records demonstrating the intention to use the trade mark for each specified good or service at the time of application.

Risk management

Companies must be aware that:

  • Enforcement actions may backfire: Initiating infringement proceedings based on broad specifications can lead to counterclaims of bad faith, potentially resulting in partial invalidation of the trade mark.
  • Portfolio audits are essential: Regularly reviewing trade mark portfolios to ensure that all registrations are defensible and align with genuine business intentions is crucial.

Conclusion

The Supreme Court’s ruling in the SkyKick case serves as a pivotal reminder of the importance of integrity and genuine intent in trade mark applications. Applicants must ensure that their trade mark specifications are precise and reflect actual or planned use to withstand legal scrutiny and maintain robust protection.

 

At Dreyfus Law Firm, we specialize in intellectual property law, offering expert guidance on trade mark registration, portfolio management, and enforcement strategies. Our team is dedicated to ensuring that your intellectual property rights are secured and maintained with the highest level of professionalism and integrity.

Dreyfus Law Firm is in partnership with a global network of attorneys specializing in Intellectual Property.

Join us on social media !

LinkedIn  

Instagram

FAQ

What constitutes bad faith in trade mark applications?

Bad faith occurs when an applicant files a trade mark application without a genuine intention to use the mark for the specified goods or services, often to prevent others from entering the market or to gain an unfair advantage.

Can a trade mark be partially invalidated for bad faith?

Yes, if bad faith is established for certain goods or services within a trade mark specification, the registration can be partially invalidated for those specific categories.

How can I ensure my trade mark application is not considered in bad faith?

Align your trade mark specifications with your current or planned business activities, avoid overly broad terms, and maintain documentation demonstrating your intention to use the mark for each specified good or service.