Esports and intellectual property: which rights should be cleared before a tournament or broadcast?

Esports arena, controller and rights documents illustrating the legal preparation of a competition.
Organising, broadcasting and reusing tournament footage involve distinct uses and permissions.

An esports tournament involves at least five categories of assets: the game, trademarks, audiovisual content, participants’ likenesses and communication materials. Buying the game or holding a player account does not give the right to organise a commercial competition or broadcast it. Before announcing the event, the organiser should check the rights needed for the competition, broadcast and planned reuse. Publisher conditions, player agreements and partner contracts should be reviewed together, rather than treated as separate administrative documents.

Problems often arise after a sponsor has signed or production has started. The permission a publisher gives for amateur tournaments (a “community” licence) may not cover a commercial event, music within the game can raise broadcast questions, and a participation agreement may omit advertising clips. Organisers should therefore connect every intended use to its rights holder and authorisation. Reviewing copyright in the content is a starting point, not a sufficient check on its own. The objective is a documented rights-clearance process that also applies to replays, archives and later promotional campaigns, under the laws and contracts relevant to the event.

Key points in 41 seconds

Watch on YouTube

Expertise and the scope of the assessment

An intellectual property assessment identifies, for a tournament or broadcast, the rights to be obtained (game, trademarks, music, players’ likenesses) and the permissions already secured. The qualifications of Nathalie Dreyfus, a court-appointed expert, can be checked through the official directories: the Paris Court of Appeal 2026 directory (PDF), under trademarks and designs, the Court of Cassation directory, 2025 edition (PDF), and the CNCEJ directory. Listings relate to defined specialisms. A private opinion, for example to audit the rights in an event, is distinct from a court-ordered expert assessment.

Separate competition rules from rights in the game

Under French law, Article L. 321-8 of the Internal Security Code defines video game competitions as contests involving at least two players or teams for a score or victory. It distinguishes organisation of these events from betting. This framework does not grant an IP licence for the game or automatically import every rule applicable to traditional sport.

Competition rules (including minors’ participation) and employment law should be checked separately. Article 102 of the Act of 7 October 2016 provides a specific fixed-term employment contract for salaried professional players. It does not turn every amateur or independent participant into an employee. Organisers must establish the actual status of contributors and distinguish employment, tournament participation and likeness permissions.

Check publisher and other rights-holder permissions

A game may combine software, graphics, sound and other creative works. The Nintendo judgment of 23 January 2014, case C-355/12, recalls that a video game is complex subject matter whose graphic and sound elements may be protected by copyright. It concerns technological protection measures on consoles and says nothing about organising competitions. Its conclusions should not be extended to uses it did not examine.

Tournament conditions may regulate event size, revenue, sponsors, permitted signs or platforms. The version applicable to the specific game and proposed format needs checking. A community licence for a small event does not necessarily authorise a commercial competition. Publisher correspondence and individual approvals should be retained alongside general terms. Teams should record which version was reviewed and any conditions attached to approval.

Broadcasting, replay and promotional clips call for separate consideration. A publicly available game does not mean every element can be exploited in advertising or a documentary. Permissions should identify relevant media, territories, periods and commercial uses. The timetable should allow clarification before commitments are made to partners. Where a licence is conditional, production needs to understand the restriction rather than assume a general clearance.

Protect tournament and team trademarks

The event name and logo should be reviewed before adoption. A trademark law assessment considers similar signs and the actual goods or services planned. Team names, social accounts and domain names should align with the rights held. Technical availability is not equivalent to legal clearance, and a registration should not be treated as permission to use another party’s branding. Indeed, an available domain name or handle is not necessarily free of existing trademark rights.

Class 41 may be relevant to cover particular competition or entertainment services. Clothing, covered by class 25, and other merchandise need specifications suited to their nature. Filing in one class does not cover every possible activity. Categories should follow the project, territory and office tools, not a generic list copied from another organiser. The proposed wording should also be checked against future commercial plans without claiming activities that are not genuinely intended.

Publisher and sponsor trademarks remain separate from the organiser’s rights. Placements, joint branding and references must comply with the agreements made. A team partnership does not automatically authorise use of the game logo. Materials presented to sponsors should avoid promising rights not yet obtained. Clear approval responsibilities help prevent unauthorised branding from entering artwork or broadcast graphics.

Review music, images and broadcast content

A live broadcast can include game footage, opening music, commentary, photographs and team-supplied videos. The source of each item and its permitted exploitation need identifying. A track authorised in one context may not cover another platform or an advertising edit. The production file should preserve licences and restrictions so that later reuse can be checked without relying on recollection.

Player agreements should distinguish participation from use of likeness or voice. They do not replace rights held by photographers, producers or other authors. Performers’ related rights should not automatically be attributed to every player: the legal classification depends on the activity and relevant conditions. Permitted media and periods should be stated, not assumed from attendance or from a general reference to filming.

The file should also cover replays, clips, subtitles and adaptations. Approval for a live stream does not necessarily cover a paid campaign months later. Production teams need a usable record of permitted uses and restrictions before editing. This helps prevent a completed asset being unusable because its music, portraits or game content was only cleared for a narrower purpose.

Connect contracts to the uses actually planned

Intellectual property contracts should define licensed rights, deliverables and responsibilities. Agreements with sponsors, agencies, teams and platforms can address approvals, withdrawals and claims. Warranties should match the rights each party can actually grant. A contributor’s promise does not replace checking the scope of their own upstream permissions.

Digital-content or NFT projects require additional review under technology contract law. A token does not automatically transfer copyright. Trademark classification follows the actual goods or services, not the label NFT alone. The organiser should define the content, access rights and licences promised before offering them commercially. The marketing description must remain consistent with those rights.

The role of the IP adviser

The IP adviser reviews contracts, obligations and responses to claims. It contributes searches, the scope of registrations and asset mapping. A factual assessment documents terms, materials and permissions. This coordination helps identify gaps before launch, without guaranteeing that disputes cannot arise or replacing rights-holder approval. Evidence should be organised so that its source and the circumstances of collection can be explained if challenged.

Illustrative case

A fictional organiser plans a local tournament under community conditions. A sponsor then offers to fund a national broadcast and advertising clips. The organiser wants opening music and player portraits. Existing agreements mainly cover participation, while the commercial scope of the original permission has not been rechecked against the expanded project.

The firm would compare the revised plan with publisher conditions, content rights and commitments offered to the sponsor. It would examine signs and the event portfolio, then define additional permissions and contractual provisions. Production would receive a usage matrix covering live broadcasts, replays, organic clips and paid advertising, with the corresponding restrictions and approval requirements.

The intended result would be a broadcast plan aligned with acquired rights, or adjusted uses before they were promised to partners. Records would be centralised to answer a challenge. This is a fictional educational example, not a client matter. It does not suggest that a particular event format automatically benefits from permission or that any outcome is assured.

A five-stage pre-broadcast check

Check the game licence, protect signs, review content, define contracts and control broadcasting.
Each intended use needs a verifiable permission before production begins.
  1. Check the licence. Review format and commercial conditions.
  2. Protect signs. Check names, logos and third-party marks.
  3. Review content. Identify rights and holders.
  4. Define contracts. Specify uses, approvals and responsibilities.
  5. Control broadcasting. Distinguish live coverage, replays, clips and advertising.

FAQ on esports rights

Does a game licence permit tournament broadcasting?

Not necessarily. User conditions and competition permissions need comparison with the broadcast format. Commercial uses and extracts may require additional rights, depending on the game and agreements. A general permission should not be inferred from access to the game.

Is the player’s agreement enough for all content?

No. Likeness permission does not replace rights held by authors, producers or game rights holders. Contributors and uses should be identified separately, including applicable restrictions. The terms should address the actual media and later exploitation proposed.

Can a sponsor freely reuse replays?

No. Reuse depends on acquired rights and the contract. Participation in the event is not a general assignment. Media, duration and adaptations need defining, particularly for advertising. The sponsor’s permission cannot exceed the organiser’s own rights.

Does an NFT transfer IP in its content?

Not automatically. Associated rights need to arise from a valid licence or assignment. The token, content and commercial promises should be distinguished to avoid misrepresenting permitted uses. Copyright ownership cannot be inferred solely from buying the token.

Why work with Dreyfus

Dreyfus assists businesses and their advisers with assets, licences and contracts, connecting the event format to documented permissions that production teams and partners can use.

Conclusion

A legally prepared tournament requires rights clearance from the game through to advertising extracts. To review your project’s assets and permissions, contact Dreyfus for an initial confidential discussion.

Dreyfus & Associés works with a global network of lawyers specialising in intellectual property.